SC imposes costs of Rs. 5 lakh for withdrawing appeals, in view of “judicial time expended” [Read Order]
In an order delivered last week, the Supreme Court imposed a cost of Rs. 5 lakh on Kerala State Electricity Board and NTPC Vidyut Vyapar Nigam Limited for withdrawing their appeals, without circulating a letter before the Bench notifying it of the withdrawal.
Granting the permission to withdraw, the Bench, comprising Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justice N.V. Ramana ordered payment of costs by the two Public sector undertakings to the Supreme Court Legal Services within four weeks, in view of the “judicial time expended”.
The two appeals were filed under Section 125 of the Electricity Act, 2003, challenging the judgment dated April 16, 2015 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, New Delhi in Appeal No. 51 of 2015.
The Court had issued notice in this case on May 11, 2015 and had made the notice returnable in six weeks. However, the counsels made a request for withdrawal when the matter was listed on October 1. The Court rapped the counsel for the way the withdrawal of the case was sought after the Judges had gone through four volumes of the petition running into 890 pages. It observed, “If you wanted to withdraw, why did you in first instance file it and persuaded us to issue notice…. This is not a drawing room where you can walk in and walk out at your own ease.”
The general practice adopted by the Courts is that in case the appeals are sought to be withdrawn, a letter should be circulated in advance, expressing their intention to do so. Hence, in case the advocates do not wish to argue the case on the next case, a letter would be issued as a courtesy to the Judges, so that they would not study the bulky files.
Read the order here.