Shops Can’t Charge Extra VAT On Items Sold On Discount: NCDRC [Read Order]

The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission recently ruled that shops cannot charge extra VAT on items sold on discounted price, observing that the MRP on the product includes all taxes, and hence it was not open for the trader to impose VAT again on the discounted price.

The question to be considered by the Commission was whether the Petitioners had indulged in unfair trade practice by charging VAT on the discounted merchandise, despite having announced a discount of “FLAT* 40%” on selected merchandise, which in actual terms works out to less than 40% of the MRP.

Answering the question in positive, the Bench comprising Justice D.K. Jain (President) and Mrs. M. Shreesha (Member) observed, “In our opinion, the advertisement in the above form is nothing but an allurement to gullible Consumers to buy the advertised merchandise at a cheaper bargain price, which itself was not intended to be the real “bargaining power” and, therefore, tantamounts to unfair trade practice, as found by both the Fora below.”

The Commission was hearing Revision Petitions filed by Woodland franchises in Chandigarh and Delhi, which had refused to refund the VAT charged to a customer on discounted merchandise. They had submitted that having charged VAT strictly as per the provisions of the State VAT Act and Legal Meteorology Act, they could not have indulged in unfair trade practices.

Relying on Section 2(d) of the Consumer Goods (Mandatory Printing of Cost of Production and Maximum Retail Price) Act, 2014, the Commission held that the rebate was on the MRP, which included all taxes and cess. It thereby upheld the order of the District Forum, which had directed the Petitioner to refund to the Complainant an amount of Rs. 119.85 illegally charged as VAT, besides paying Rs. 5,000 as compensation for mental agony and harassment, and Rs. 2,000 as litigation costs.

Read the order here.

This article has been made possible because of financial support from Independent and Public-Spirited Media Foundation.

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*

*

  • Arvind Mahajan says:

    Sir, as per the above order of Hon’ble NCDRC VAT cannot be charged on discounted MRP. Can a person get a Police complaint regarding cheating ,registered against the erring store selling product at discount on MRP and charging VAT extra from the customer despite making the seller aware of the above said order? Please advice. Regards.

  • Yadvendra says:

    Last weekend I visited Home Centre & Home Town in TGIP, the stores is still charging VAT on discounted items.

  • B says:

    Has the Consumer Goods (Mandatory Printing of Cost of Production and Maximum Retail Price) Act been notified? Cannot seem to find a copy of the notified Act anywhere. Even the bookhouses do not have a bare act in store.

  • Avinash Murkute says:

    Excellent decision. Many traders including Megamart, Venus Traders and others are involved at Pune. Before reading this article, I just protested to Venus Traders Pune to not to indulge in such activities and got this order in the afternoon. Congratulations to Rakesh Sharma who fought for this. Shall be sending personal note to him at his address mentioned in the petition / order.

  • Pravat Kumar Samal says:

    Very good info on judgements.

Top