Singhvi: proportionality is not the first test,... ... Sabarimala Reference : Live Updates From Supreme Court 9-Judge Bench [Day 15]

Singhvi: proportionality is not the first test, first is reasonable restriction.

on whether article 26 is subject to other limitations- mylords may hold that subject to other provision may be that all parts of part III which are horizontal may trump article 25(1) but not the non-horizontal rights. horizontal rights are 15(2), 17, etc. I don't agree that 14 and 19 are horizontal rights.