The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Ernakulam, comprising President D.B. Binu, Member V. Ramachandran and Member Sreevidya T.N., has directed the Kerala State Road Transport Corporation (KSRTC) to pay ₹45,000 to a woman whose 73-year-old husband suffered a wrist fracture after falling inside a KSRTC bus during a journey.
Background
The complainant, Chandrika Mohandas, approached the Consumer Commission alleging deficiency in service on the part of KSRTC following an accident involving her husband during a bus journey.
On October 7, 2023, the complainant, her 73-year-old husband Mohandas, and their family boarded a KSRTC bus from Edappally for a pleasure trip to Malakkappara organised by a local residents' association.
Shortly after the journey commenced, near Kalamassery, the bus crew allegedly instructed her elderly husband to vacate his seat to accommodate passengers who had booked seats from Angamaly. Later, during the journey, the driver suddenly applied the brakes, causing Mohandas to fall heavily and land on his left hand.
He sustained injuries to his left wrist, accompanied by severe pain and swelling. He subsequently underwent treatment at Sanjoe Hospital, where he was diagnosed with a Colles fracture of the left wrist. The medical record dated October 11, 2023, recorded the injury as resulting from a fall inside the bus on October 9, 2023.
The complainant alleged that the accident occurred due to the negligent manner in which the bus was operated and that KSRTC had failed to ensure passenger safety.
She sought reimbursement of medical expenses amounting to ₹52,343, besides compensation for the physical pain, mental agony and other hardships arising from her husband's injury.
Despite being served with notice, KSRTC did not file its version, following which the Commission proceeded with the matter ex parte.
Commission's Observations
The Commission examined the documentary evidence produced by the complainant, including the bus ticket, hospital records, medical bills and treatment documents.
It observed that the bus ticket (Ext. A3) established the consumer relationship between the complainant and the transport provider. The medical records, including the discharge summary and treatment documents, substantiated the injuries sustained by her husband and the treatment undergone by him.
The Commission noted that the medical records confirmed a left wrist Colles fracture following a fall inside the bus. It also considered the medical bills establishing expenses of ₹52,343.
Emphasising the responsibility of a public transport service provider towards passenger safety, the Commission observed that KSRTC was expected to ensure adequate safety arrangements and provide necessary assistance to passengers in the event of an accident.
It further considered the circumstances of the incident, the nature of the injuries and the financial and physical hardships suffered by the complainant's family. The Commission found that the evidence placed on record established the complainant's entitlement to relief for the deficiency in service.
Decision
Allowing the complaint, the Commission directed KSRTC to pay ₹40,000 as compensation towards the physical pain, mental agony, financial loss and other hardships suffered by the complainant.
The Corporation was also directed to pay ₹5,000 towards litigation costs.
The amounts are to be paid within 45 days from the date of receipt of the order. In the event of non-payment within the stipulated period, the amounts awarded under both heads will carry interest at 9% per annum from the date of the order until realisation.