Myanmar Committed Genocide Against Rohingyas : International Court Of Justice
| The Court held that decades of discrimination and hate speeches contributed to genocidal acts towards Rohingyas.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has held that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State during the 2017 military clearance operations, finding that the only reasonable inference from the Myanmar military's actions was an intention to destroy a substantial part of the protected group.
In a landmark judgment delivered on Thursday (November 19), a nine-judge majority of the 15-member Court found that Myanmar violated its obligations under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Genocide Convention).
"The only reasonable inference that can explain Myanmar's actions is an intention to destroy a substantial part of the protected group, namely the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State," the Court held.
The judgment was delivered in an application brought by The State of Gambia.
The Court found that Myanmar's security forces committed acts falling under Article II (a), (b) and (d) of the Genocide Convention, namely killing members of the protected group, causing serious bodily or mental harm to them, and imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group.
However, the Court held that the evidence did not conclusively establish the commission of genocidal acts under Article II (c), which concerns deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the physical destruction of a group.
Decades of discrimination, hate speech contributed to genocidal intent
The Court observed that the context surrounding the 2017 clearance operations, including decades of discriminatory legislation and a military-sponsored hate speech campaign, created an atmosphere conducive to the violence perpetrated by Myanmar's security forces.
The Court also considered the selective targeting of Rohingya villages, the burning and razing of their homes, widespread sexual violence and attacks against children.
It noted that the manner in which the Rohingya were forcibly displaced, together with the destruction of their homes, sent a clear message that they had nothing to return to.
The evidence of brutal sexual violence and the targeting of children also supported an inference that there was a desire to destroy the foundations of the Rohingya group.
Applying the 'only reasonable inference' test laid down in its earlier genocide jurisprudence, the Court rejected Myanmar's arguments that the operations could be explained as counter-insurgency measures, an attempt to forcibly displace the population or an effort to punish the Rohingya.
The Court observed that the scale and nature of Myanmar's actions, including the large numbers of people killed, injured or displaced and widespread brutal attacks against women and children, went well beyond what would be required to punish the population.
It accordingly concluded that it was fully convinced that Myanmar committed genocide with the intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population.
Myanmar violated obligations to prevent and punish genocide
The Court also found that Myanmar violated its obligation under Article I of the Genocide Convention to prevent genocide committed by individuals alongside its security forces.
It held that Myanmar knew or should have known of a serious risk of genocidal acts being committed by non-Rohingya civilians participating in the 2017 clearance operations, but manifestly refrained from taking measures within its power to prevent such acts.
On the question of direct and public incitement to genocide, however, the Court did not find Myanmar responsible for inciting private persons to commit genocide.
Although it found that military-linked Facebook accounts disseminated anti-Rohingya messages that encouraged and legitimised violence, the evidence did not conclusively establish that the posts were made with the specific intent to destroy the group or constituted direct appeals for genocide.
The Court further found that Myanmar violated its obligation to punish genocide and other acts enumerated under Article III of the Convention.
It observed that the United Nations Fact-Finding Mission's September 2018 report had provided sufficient information to warrant the initiation of proceedings for genocide, including against named individuals.
Myanmar therefore had reasonable grounds to suspect that genocide might have been committed in its territory and sufficient evidence to commence an investigation.
However, the Court found that Myanmar had not conducted prompt, effective, thorough, independent and impartial investigations into the 2017 clearance operations.
It noted that there had been no systematic investigation into crimes committed by the Myanmar military, including the role of its command structure. The limited court-martial proceedings resulted in minimal penalties, while no individual had been identified, charged, prosecuted or punished for genocide or other offences under Article III of the Convention.
The Court also found that Myanmar had violated Article V of the Convention by failing to enact necessary domestic legislation giving full effect to its obligations under the treaty.
Myanmar directed to facilitate return of displaced Rohingya, compensate victims
On the question of remedies, the Court directed Myanmar to adopt measures of restitution for the harm caused to the Rohingya population.
These include:
Allowing and facilitating the safe, voluntary and dignified return of Rohingya displaced by Myanmar's wrongful acts and reunification of their families.
Returning or replacing individual and collective property lost or damaged as a result of the violations.
Facilitating the search for disappeared persons and recovery, identification and dignified reburial of those killed, in accordance with Rohingya traditions.
Providing physical and psychological rehabilitation to Rohingya who suffered bodily or mental injuries.
Ensuring protection of the Rohingya against discrimination and persecution.
Myanmar has been directed to submit a report to the Court within two years, setting out the restitution measures adopted and, where full restitution is materially impossible, specifying the amount and modalities of compensation.
The Court further directed Myanmar to provide assurances and guarantees of non-repetition of the violations.
Case: T