The Supreme Court has clarified that although the vesting of private forests in the Kerala Government under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971, takes place automatically by operation of law, such automatic vesting applies only to lands that satisfy the statutory definition of 'private forest' under Section 2(f) of the Act.

The Court held that vesting does not depend on demarcation of boundaries or issuance of a notification under Rule 2A of the Rules. However, the land must first qualify as a private forest under the Act.

The Court held so and dismissed an appeal filed by the Kerala government which challenged concurrent findings that 12 acres at Nilambur Amsom, Edakkara Village, Malappuram, is not a private forest and did not vest in the State government under the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971.

A bench of Justice PS Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe further observed that the Forest Tribunal's finding, which was affirmed by the High Court, that the land was neither a wooded area nor an enclave on the appointed day, May 10, 1971, cannot be termed as perverse warranting interference in the present appeal. The bench also rejected Kerala government's application seeking to place on record a 1990 notification, observing that the explanation for producing the document so late itself exhibits lack of due diligence.

The respondents claimed that the land was leased to their father in 1960 which he cultivated until his death in 1976. After Forest Department officials obstructed their agricultural operations in 1988, they applied under Section 8 of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act seeking a declaration that the land is not a private forest and has not vested in the Kerala government. In the alternative, they also claimed exemption under Sections 3(2) and 3(3) of the Act.

The Forest Tribunal first dismissed the application in 1991, observing that the respondents had not proved their father's possession on the appointed day. In 2000, the High Court held that the respondents had not proved ownership and remanded the matter back to the Tribunal on the question whether the land was covered by the Act under a valid notification or by the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949 (MPPF Act).

On remand, the Tribunal in 2001 held that the land is not a private forest. It found that there was no evidence that the land was governed by the MPPF Act, as both Range Officers admitted there was no document to establish it; the notification took in only surveyed portions of Edakkara Village, whereas the subject land is unsurveyed, and its publication under Rule 2A of the Rules was not proved; and the Commissioner found only bamboo clusters less than 10 years old and four wells, so the land was not a forest in 1971.

In 2008, the High Court affirmed the Tribunal's finding and held that vesting under Section 3(1) is automatic if the land is a private forest. Since the land is in the erstwhile Malabar District, it had to be shown to be land to which the MPPF Act applied immediately before the appointed day.

Thereafter the Kerala government filed an appeal before the Supreme Court, which asked it to file an affidavit on the status of the properties to the west, north and east. The Chief Conservator of Forests then inspected the land and apprised that it lies within Vested Forest Committee covered with natural vegetation, and has trees more than 75 years old. The State government also produced the 1900 notification issued under the Madras Forest Act, 1882, for the first time before the Supreme Court. Per contra, the respondents placed on record photographs and affidavits of local residents, contending that the land was cultivated till about 1980.

Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta appeared for the Kerala government to argue that the High Court erred in not examining whether the land is a private forest under Section 2(f)(1)(ii) of the Act. It was also contended that no notification is needed and that vesting is automatic. Reliance was placed on the 1900 notification to contend that the land is a private forest and sought to remit the matter to the High Court.

Per contra, Senior Advocate A Hariprasad appeared for the respondents to support the concurrent findings, arguing that under Section 2(c) of the MPPF Act an 'owner' includes a lessee or any person entitled to possession, so a registered title document is not necessary. It was submitted that the 1900 notification does not indicate that the land is a private vested forest, and that it was produced 25 years after its date, by which time the topography would have been changed beyond recognition.

Perusing the submissions, the Supreme Court analysed the statutory scheme of the Act and explained as under:

“Section 2(f)(1) of the Act contemplates two categories of private forests in relation to the Malabar District. The first one being the land to which the MPPF Act applied immediately before the appointed day, subject to the exclusions contained therein. The second one being any forest not owned by the Government to which the MPPF Act did not apply, including waste lands which are enclaves within wooded areas.”

The bench further held that:

“A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it evident that, with effect from the appointed day, i.e., 10.05.1971, the ownership and possession of all private forests in the State stood vested in the Government by operation of law. The vesting is automatic and does not depend upon the demarcation of boundaries under Section 6 of the Act or the issuance of a notification under Rule 2A of the Rules. However, what vests in the Government is only a 'private forest' as defined in Section 2(f) of the Act.”

Relying on Kunjanam Antony v State of Kerala and State of Kerala v Popular Estates, the bench observed that under a Section 8 proceeding, the burden of proving that the land is not a private forest lies on the person who asserts it. It further added that “the standard of proof is that of preponderance of probabilities, and the claimant is not required to prove every historical fact with certainty.”

The respondents had relied on the Commissioner's report which showed young bamboo clusters, four wells and private holdings around the land. On this, the bench observed that the State, which holds the records of survey and notification, examined two Range Officers who both admitted there was no document showing the land was governed by the MPPF Act and that no evidence was led by the State with regards to the nature of the subject land as on the cutoff date or immediately before the appointed day under the MPPF Act.

The Court observed that the statement of the respondents' witness, that the Forest Department claims the adjoining lands, “does not amount to an admission that the subject land was a private forest, or the subject land is situated contiguous to a private forest.”

The Court further noted that in Bhavani Tea and Produce Co. Ltd v State of Kerala it was held that 'forest' means a large tract of uncultivated land covered with trees and underwood, excluding lands on which human skill and labour have been spent for agricultural operations. Applying this, the Tribunal held on the Commissioner's report and other material that the land was neither a wooded area nor an enclave on the appointed day, which the High Court affirmed and which the Supreme Court said cannot be called perverse.

With regards to the Kerala government's application seeking to file a 1990 notification, the bench reiterated that additional evidence at the appellate stage is allowed only if the party proves that, despite due diligence, it could not be produced earlier.

“A party cannot be permitted to adduce evidence to fill up the lacunae or to set up a new case,” it was observed.

The bench also held that the notification does not contain any description by which the land can be identified or from which it can be inferred that it forms part of a contiguous area. According to the State government's own affidavit, the private forest pertains to the Kariam Muriam block forest, and there is no material to show that it is contiguous to the subject land. It remarked that by relying on the notification, the State “has attempted to set up a case which is inconsistent with the case itself set up by it that the subject land was a private forest which vested with the State Government under the Act.”

Finding no merit in the Kerala government's appeal, the Supreme Court dismissed the plea.

“We do not find any merit in this appeal, the same fails and is therefore, dismissed.”

Appearances:

For Appellants: Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Zulfiker Ali P. S, AOR; Mr. Manish Sindhwani, Adv.; Ms. Lakshmi Sree P, Adv.; Ms. Anna Oommen, Adv.; Ms. Lebina Baby, Adv.

For Respondents: Mr. A.Hariprasad, Sr. Adv.; Ms. Usha Nandini V., AOR; Mr. Biju P Raman, Adv.; Mr. John Thomas Arakal, Adv.; Ms. Nandana Harikrishnan, Adv.; Ms. Dimple Nagpal, Adv.

Tags: