Past Misconduct May Be Relevant To Decide Penalty For Subsequent Misconduct, But Cannot Fill Gaps In Fresh Charges: Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has held that previous misconduct for which an employee has already been punished cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct to impose another penalty. It clarified that an employee's past service record may be considered while determining punishment for subsequent misconduct independently established, but cannot be used to compensate for deficiencies in proving the fresh charges.
"The previous misconduct for which an employee has already been subjected to disciplinary action cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct for the purpose of imposing another penalty. The past service record may, where relevant and in accordance with the applicable rules, be considered while determining the penalty for a subsequent misconduct which has independently been established. It cannot, however, be used to supply the deficiency in proof of the charges in the present proceedings," the Court observed.
The Court made the observation while setting aside the removal from service of a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) constable who had tendered his resignation amid serious medical complications suffered by his wife during pregnancy.
The Bench held that the charges of misconduct against the constable were not adequately established and that the punishment of removal was grossly disproportionate to the conduct attributed to him.
A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh directed the reinstatement of constable Sumit Kumar, with all consequential benefits and 50% of the back wages from the date of his removal until reinstatement.
Kumar had sought leave in December 2017 to care for his wife, who was suffering from serious medical complications following a miscarriage and surgery. After his request was initially declined, he submitted a conditional resignation through the departmental grievance portal, claiming that he was under acute mental stress. He was subsequently granted 12 days' leave.
The CISF initiated disciplinary proceedings against him, alleging that he had attempted to pressurise the administration through his resignation, circulated a video of his wife and used relatives to threaten senior officials. The inquiry officer found all charges proved, and Kumar was removed from service in May 2018.
On the allegation that Kumar had circulated a video of his wife accusing the CISF administration of harassing him by denying leave, the judgment authored by Justice Sharma found that the inquiry had failed to establish his involvement. It noted that a departmental witness had stated that the video was received from a different mobile number and had not been sent by Kumar. The record also showed that Kumar was present at the CISF unit when the video was recorded at the hospital.
The Court held that there was no satisfactory evidence to establish that Kumar had circulated the video, caused it to be circulated or instigated his relatives to threaten departmental authorities.
“The mere fact that the video concerned the Appellant's wife, or that certain persons claiming to be his relatives contacted the departmental authorities, would not, in the absence of evidence connecting their conduct to the Appellant, be sufficient to sustain the charge against him,” the Court observed.
It added that Kumar could not be held responsible merely because of his relationship with the persons alleged to have contacted the department.
The Court further held that previous minor penalties imposed on an employee cannot be treated as fresh misconduct or used to fill gaps in proving subsequent charges. While past service records may be considered while determining punishment for independently established misconduct, they cannot substitute proof of the charges.
The Court also found that Kumar was supplied Hindi translations of the documents relied upon by the department only after the prosecution evidence had concluded. His request for a defence assistant was also rejected, despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. These circumstances, it held, deprived him of an effective opportunity to defend himself.
Observing that even the submission of a conditional resignation had to be considered in the context of his wife's serious medical condition, the Court held that his conduct did not disclose any grave or deliberate indiscipline warranting removal from service.
“…the circumstances in which the Appellant submitted his resignation, particularly the serious medical condition of his wife and his request for further leave, were relevant considerations which required due examination before attributing to him an intention to pressurise the administration.”, the Court said.
Declining to order a fresh inquiry, the Court quashed the removal and directed Kumar's immediate reinstatement with 50% back wages.
Appearance:
For Petitioner(s) Mr. Rakesh Kumar Khanna, Sr. Adv. Ms. Amita Singh Kalkal, AOR Ms. Aditi Gupta, Adv. Mr. Aditya P Khanna, Adv. Ms. Arushi Jindal, Adv. Mr. Jatin Parashar, Adv. Mr. Devinder N. Grover, Adv. Ms. Vijay Lakshmi Grover, Adv. Mr. Govind Kashyap, Adv.
For Respondent(s) Mr. Brijender Chahar, A.S.G. Ms. Pooja Chahar, Adv. Mr. Anmol Chandan, Adv. Ms. Nasadiya Singh, Adv. Mr. Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Adv. Mr. Amrish Kumar- 2986, AOR Mr. Arvind Kumar Sharma-aor, Adv. Dr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Adv.