Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Supreme Court on Thursday (October 8) held that a failure of the accused to furnish an explanation regarding the seizure made at his place cannot be regarded as incriminating material against him, and the burden of proving the valid seizure remains with the prosecution. A bench of Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar heard the case where the accused's acquittal in an...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Supreme Court on Thursday (October 8) held that a failure of the accused to furnish an explanation regarding the seizure made at his place cannot be regarded as incriminating material against him, and the burden of proving the valid seizure remains with the prosecution.

A bench of Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar heard the case where the accused's acquittal in an alleged offence of criminal breach of trust (under Section 409 IPC) was reversed by the Bombay High Court Aurangabad Bench, where the High Court gave credence to the seizure of documents made at his house, despite being made in defiance of Section 100 of the Cr.P.C., particularly, the failure of the prosecution to supply the list of seized items to the accused, and the panch witnesses going hostile.

Initially, the trial court found that the procedure prescribed under Section 100(7) Cr.P.C. was not followed during the search and seizure. However, the High Court relied on the testimony of the Investigating Officer (“IO”) without any further corroboration to deem the seizure to be valid. Moreover, the High Court held that the absence of the appellant's signature on the seizure panchnama was not significant and relied on the IO's testimony. It reasoned that there was no reason for the police officer to falsely depose about the seizure.

Setting aside the High Court's decision, the judgment authored by Justice Chandurkar refused to give credence to the seizure process, noting “there was infraction of the requirements of Sections 100(4) and 100(7) of the Code due to its non-compliance.”

“In this scenario, the seizure could not be held to be duly proved solely on the basis of deposition of the IO without any further corroboration. There is no explanation given by the IO as to why a list of the articles seized from the appellant's house was not furnished to him.”, the Court observed.

The Court specifically rejected the High Court's approach of treating the allegedly seized documents as an incriminating circumstance which the appellant was required to explain.

“We, therefore, find that the High Court erred in relying upon the seizure of the said articles and further observing that the same was an incriminating circumstance against the appellant, for which he had not furnished any explanation. The burden of proving a valid seizure of the articles was on the prosecution, but it failed to prove the same, in accordance with law.”, the Court said.

It further observed that the High Court had erred in relying upon the alleged seizure and then drawing an adverse inference from the appellant's failure to explain the documents.

Non-compliance with Section 100 CrPC not automatically fatal, but may affect evidentiary weight

The Court nevertheless clarified that every violation of Section 100 CrPC does not automatically invalidate a search or seizure.

"Non-compliance of the requirements of Section 100 of the Code by itself would not vitiate a seizure and the same would be an irregularity in the investigation," the Court said, emphasising that the non-compliance had to be considered cumulatively with other factors that contribute to doubting the prosecution case, the same would weigh in favour of the appellant.

Since the fact that the two seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution, the IO himself had admitted several shortcomings, and the prosecution's documentary case suffered from other serious deficiencies, the Court refused to sustain the conviction based on the seizure.

“It is true that non-compliance of the requirements of Section 100 of the Code by itself would not vitiate a seizure and the same would be an irregularity in the investigation. However, when this factor is considered cumulatively with other factors that contribute to doubting the prosecution case, the same would weigh in favour of the appellant, especially in an appeal against acquittal.”, the Court observed.

Noting that the prosecution also failed to establish both entrustment of property and dishonest intention, which were essential ingredients of the offence under Section 409 IPC, the Court restored the trial court's decision of acquittal.

As a result, the Appeal was allowed.

Appearance:

For Appellant(s) : Mr. B.H. Marlapalle, Sr. Adv. Mr. Sudhanshu S Choudhari, Sr. Adv. Mr. Vatsalya Vigya, AOR Mr. Ajit Wagh, Adv. Ms. Aanchal Rathore, Adv. Mr. Avinish Kumar Saurabh, Adv. Ms. Gautami Yadav, Adv. Ms. Pranjal Chapalgaonkar, Adv. Mr. Yash Singhania, Adv.

For Respondent(s) :Mr. Shrirang B. Varma, Adv. Mr. Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Adv. Mr. Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, AOR Mr. Harshavardhan V. Ghadge, Adv.

Headnote

Criminal Law & Procedure – Indian Penal Code, 1860 – Sections 405 and 409 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Sections 100(4), 100(7), 235(2) and 386(a) – Indian Evidence Act, 1872 – Section 114(g) – Criminal Breach of Trust by Public Servant – Reversal of Acquittal – Non-Production of Primary Registers – Adverse Inference – Defective Search and Seizure – Mandatory Hearing on Sentence upon First-Time Conviction by Appellate Court – Held that To establish an offence under Section 409 IPC, the prosecution must strictly prove both the entrustment of property (or dominion over it) and dishonest misappropriation or conversion - Where the complainant department failed to produce primary accounting records such as the original cashbook, daily cash handover register, audit report, and stock register of receipt books despite repeated demands by the Investigating Officer as well as applications filed by the defence, foundational proof of entrustment is lacking - The trial court rightly drew an adverse inference against the prosecution under Section 114(g) of the Evidence Act, and the High Court gravely erred in shifting the burden of proof onto the accused to prove his innocence - While non-compliance with search and seizure formalities under Sections 100(4) and 100(7) CrPC does not per se vitiate a trial, where both panch witnesses turn hostile and the Investigating Officer fails to obtain the accused's signature or supply a copy of the seizure list without explanation, the seizure cannot be held proved solely on the uncorroborated testimony of the police officer and weighs against the prosecution when assessed cumulatively - In an appeal against acquittal, the appellate court must accord due weight to the presumption of innocence (which is reinforced by an acquittal) and the trial court's assessment of witness demeanour, and ought not to interfere merely because another view is possible - where an appellate court reverses an order of acquittal under Section 386(a) CrPC and convicts an accused for the first time, it is under a mandatory duty analogous to Section 235(2) CrPC to adjourn the matter and afford the convict an opportunity of being heard on the quantum of sentence before passing sentence. [Relied on R. Venkatakrishnan v. Central Bureau of Investigation, (2009) 11 SCC 737; Mukesh Kumar Yadav v. The State (UT of Andaman & Nicobar Islands) Etc., 2026 INSC 559; Kumar Exports v. Sharma Carpets, (2009) 2 SCC 513 / 2008 INSC 1437; Paras 14 - 24].

Tags: