Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court has acquitted a man convicted in an alleged honour killing of two women believed to be involved in prostitution, based on a statement recorded during the police investigation, holding that such statements cannot be treated as substantive evidence of guilt, even when contradictions between a witness's police statement and courtroom testimony are duly proved after the witness turns hostile.

The Supreme Court has held that merely because a witness is declared hostile during trial, their previous statement to the police cannot be treated as substantive evidence to establish the guilt of the accused.

The Court clarified that statements recorded by the police under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) can be used only for the limited purpose of contradicting a witness in the manner prescribed under Section 145 of the Evidence Act. Even if such a contradiction is proved, it does not make the previous statement evidence of the facts narrated therein.

The Court made the observation while acquitting a Haryana man, Naresh, who was convicted of murdering two women, Suman and Shakuntla, in Bhiwani district in April 2011. The Court set aside his conviction and life sentence, holding that the prosecution had failed to establish his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

“…even a proved contradiction serves only to impeach the credit of the witness under Section 155(3) of the Evidence Act. It may lead the Court to view what he has said in court with caution, or to reject his testimony altogether. It does not, however, make his previous statement evidence of the facts narrated therein. In other words, a proved contradiction may show that the witness is unreliable, but it cannot show that what he told the police is true.”, observed a bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh.

In essence, the Court held that since Section 162(1) Cr.P.C. prohibits using statements recorded under Section 161 as substantive evidence, their evidentiary character does not change merely because a witness turns hostile. This means, even when an earlier police statement is duly proved to contradict the witness's testimony in court, it cannot be relied upon as substantive evidence of the facts stated therein.

In the present case, the prosecution alleged that the Appellant and another accused had committed the murder of two women, who were found dead at their respective residences in 2011.

The Trial Court convicted both accused and sentenced them to death. While the High Court acquitted co-accused, it upheld the Appellant's conviction, though it commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment.

Before the Supreme Court, it was pointed out that the material witnesses, including the informant and persons projected as eyewitnesses, had turned hostile and denied the statements attributed to them by the police under Section 161 Cr.P.C. In other words, the conviction had been sustained substantially by relying on the witnesses' earlier police statements arraying the Appellant in an FIR registered on a hearsay information, even though the witnesses had not supported the prosecution's case during trial.

Rejecting this approach, the judgment authored by Justice Sharma clarified that the proviso to Section 162 Cr.P.C. permits a statement recorded by the police to be used to contradict its maker, but it does not make the statement substantive evidence of the facts stated therein.

According to the court, when the witness had resiled from its police statements, then even the proved contradiction would not treat the earlier police statements as a substantive piece of evidence.

“In the present case, it is true that the statements recorded by the police from the hostile witnesses named the Appellant. Not one of these witnesses, however, implicated him in court, either before or after being declared hostile. Whatever incriminates the Appellant is to be found only in those statements, which the witnesses disowned and which Section 162 CrPC does not permit to be used as evidence.”, the Court observed.

Further, the Court rejected the State's reliance on the 2011 Supreme Court's ruling in Bhagwan Dass v. State (NCT of Delhi) to contend that the previous (police) statements could be taken into consideration in view of the proviso to Section 162(1) CrPC. The Court said that the State's reliance on Bhagwan Dass was misplaced, as in that case, the previous police statements of the witness were not taken into account in isolation; rather, there existed several other corroborative pieces of material, independent of the witness statement, to bring home the charges beyond reasonable doubt.

Also, the Court found the Appellant's disclosure statements to be unreliable, as the recovered items were not proved in accordance with Section 27 of the Evidence Act, as the words used by him had never been narrated in evidence. Moreover, the recovered items bore no connection with the fatal injuries.

As a result, the appeal was allowed, thereby overturning the murder conviction.

Appearance:

For Appellant(s) : Mr. D.N.Goburdhun, Sr. Adv. Mrs. Anjani Aiyagari- 1155, AOR Mr. Jayanta Kumar Biswas, Adv. Ms. Vandana Khanorkar, Adv.

For Respondent(s) :Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Sr. Adv. Mr. Samar Vijay Singh, AOR Ms. Srishti Mishra, Adv. Ms. Sabarni Som, Adv. Mr. Aman Dev Sharma, Adv. Mr. Gaj Singh, Adv.

Tags: