Click the Play button to listen to article

Observing that prior consent of a gram panchayat is mandatory before proceeding with land acquisition in scheduled areas under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (2013 Act), the Supreme Court on Wednesday (November 18) set aside the land acquisition proceedings in Schedule village areas of Sundergarh district of Odisha for the Dalmia Cement plant after finding that the requisite consent of the gram panchayats was absent.

Interpreting Section 41(3) of the 2013 Act, which governs the consent requirement for land acquisition in schedule areas, a bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held that the prior consent requirement under the provision is mandatory, and its non-compliance would render the acquisition proceedings vitiated.

“Once the government finally decides to proceed with land acquisition in such areas, it has already crossed the stages contemplated in sub-sections (1) and (2), and has entered the stage contemplated by sub-section (3). At this juncture, the mandatory requirement of sub-section (3) cannot be negated by referring to the directory nature of the words used in sub-sections (1) and (2). To do so would not only be against the principle of simple and textual interpretation of the statute, but would also amount to a gross violation of the language and scheme of the statute. Therefore, we hold that the requirement of Section 41(3) of the Act is mandatory in nature, and there is nothing to suggest it to be directory or advisory.”, the Court observed.

The Orissa High Court decision holding the consent requirement to be directory was set aside. The judgment authored by Justice Sharma disagreed with the High Court's reasoning that the consent requirement was directory and said that the High Court sought to treat the mandatory requirement as a mere paper formality.

“Unfortunately, the impugned judgment has the effect of reducing a mandatory statutory requirement into a paper formality. What is more concerning is that the present case is on an even worse footing. Far from a meaningful consent, there is not even paper consent of Gram Sabha in this case. This consent was required to be taken on Form M as per Rule 41 of Odisha Rules, and there is no such material on record. Contrarily, it is the admitted position that both the Gram Sabha(s) had expressly rejected the proposal at the threshold through the resolutions passed on 26.01.2020. Nevertheless, the respondents proceeded unhindered on the path of illegality.”, the Court said.

The Court also held that where land is acquired for a private company, consent of at least 80% of the affected families under Section 2(2)(b) must be obtained along with the Social Impact Assessment (SIA), before the government considers the acquisition proposal. Subsequent consent cannot cure the failure to comply with this requirement.

The acquisition process was further found defective because no public hearing was actually conducted during the SIA exercise and a company-linked advisor was included in the Expert Group, compromising its independence.

Rejecting the argument that the mining lease under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, authorised the company to undertake mining, the Court observed that a mining lease cannot override the proprietary rights of third-party landowners or dispense with the safeguards under the 2013 Act.

“A bilateral relationship based on lease between two parties cannot affect the proprietary rights of third-party land owners, who are independent to such lease. The mineral lease provides mineral concession to the lessee and royalty to the State. The landowner has no privity with it and has no benefit to derive from the same. Suffice to note that a contractual arrangement between State and mining lessee cannot affect third parties in the manner urged by the company.”, the Court observed.

The Court allowed the appeal and quashed the acquisition notifications and consequential orders, while clarifying that fresh acquisition proceedings may be initiated in accordance with law.

Appearance:

For Appellant(s) : Mr. Sanjay Parikh, Sr. Adv. Mr. Abhimanue Shrestha, AOR Ms. Sridevi Panikkar, Adv. Mr. Ashok Kumar Minj, Adv. Ms. Kritika, Adv. Mr. Satwik Parikh, Adv.

For Respondent(s) : Mr. K. M. Nataraj, A.S.G. Mr. Pitambar Acharya, Advocate General Ms. Divya Roy- 1820, AOR Ms. Deveshi Mishra, Adv. Mr. Vinayak Sharma, Adv. Mr. Ruturaj Satpathy, Adv. Mr. Yogya Rajpurohit, Adv. Mr. Rakesh Dwivedi, Sr. Adv. Mr. Mahesh Agarwal, Adv. Mr. M.s. Ananth, Adv. Ms. Kamakshi Sehgal, Adv. Mr. Paranjai Singh, Adv. Mr. Eklavya Dwivedi, Adv. Mr. Mohd. Yasir, Adv. Mr. E. C. Agrawala, AOR

Tags: