Supreme Court Rejects UP Housing Board's Rs 388 Crore Demand From Builder For Alternate Plot Land Given In Exchange For Acquired Land
The Supreme Court on Tuesday (November 17) rejected plea filed by the Uttar Pradesh government and Uttar Pradesh Avas Evam Vikas Parishad (Housing Board) challenging an Allahabad High Court judgment that had set aside a demand of Rs 388 crore raised against real estate developer M/s Gaursons India Pvt. Ltd.
A bench of Justice PS Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe upheld the High Court's decision to quash the Chief Secretary's June 2022 order and the consequential demand notice of September 2022.
The matter pertains to land of Gaursons' predecessors-in-interest, which the Housing Board acquired for its Vasundhara Scheme in Ghaziabad. In 1995, the Supreme Court disposed of the Housing Board's appeal on a compromise under which the acquired land (12.047 acres) would be adjusted in the scheme, to be used for water purification-related construction with the rest kept open, and no party would pay any value or compensation for the exchange.
In a 2004 Exchange Deed, two parcels (Khasra Nos. 948 and 1454) in Arthala village were allotted to the predecessors-in-interest which were sold to Gaursons in 2005. It later emerged that the land had already been resumed by the District Magistrate in 1994 for a bird sanctuary. After years of litigation, the Housing Board executed a second Exchange Deed in 2016, giving Gaursons alternative land in the Siddharth Vihar Yojana. Gaursons had paid Rs 32.45 crore as land conversion charges. It built 2,476 general houses and 450 EWS/LIG houses on the land, which were sold to homebuyers.
After a PIL in the High Court and a Special Investigation Team (SIT) report, the Chief Secretary's order of June 2022 directed that the land be allotted to Gaursons at the current bulk sale rate subsequent to which the Housing Board issued the Rs 388 crore demand notice. The High Court set aside two conditions (ii & iii) of the order and the demand notice. Thereafter, an appeal was filed before the Supreme Court.
Before the Supreme Court, Attorney General R Venkataramani and Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati appeared for the Uttar Pradesh government, and Senior Advocate PN Misra appeared for the Housing Board, arguing that the 1995 order and Clause 4 of the 2004 Exchange Deed limited the land to water purification use, yet the 2005 sale deed described it as residential. It was also argued that the 2016 Exchange Deed was executed without regard to those covenants, and that the SIT's findings indicated collusion between Housing Board officials and Gaursons.
Per contra, Respondent 1 (Gaursons/R1) submitted that the Housing Board had retained and commercially monetised the originally acquired land in the older, higher-value Vasundhara Scheme without paying compensation, therefore it could not treat the 2016 Exchange Deed as a fresh commercial allotment and demand the bulk sale rate, and that Gaursons had already paid Rs 32.45 crore as conversion charges.
The Court first examined the 1995 compromise, and held that the expression 'said land' in Clause 3 referred to the acquired land of the predecessors-in-interest, which was to be adjusted within the scheme, and not to any other parcel later allotted.
“The compromise does not attach a perpetual restriction to whatever land the Housing Board might eventually give in exchange,” the bench observed.
The bench noted that the Housing Board had an obligation under the compromise to identify and allot an alternative parcel without any encumbrance. It found that the Housing Board allotted Khasra Nos. 948 and 1454 despite the District Magistrate's order resuming the land for a bird sanctuary, and despite revenue records showing them as lake and banjar land. The bench held as under:
“Clearly, no due diligence was exercised by the Housing Board while making the alternative allotment, and the predecessors-in-interest of the first respondent, for no fault of theirs, could not take possession of the said land due to the unlawful allotment made by the Housing Board. Therefore, we agree with the High Court that the 2004 Exchange Deed had failed and the Housing Board was obligated to make an alternative land arrangement for the acquired land. Since the 2004 Exchange Deed does not survive owing to the Housing Board's failure to exercise caution in making the alternative allotment, the stipulation in Clause 4 of the Deed would not bind the first respondent. This aspect is discussed further in the context of the 2016 Exchange Deed. For the same reason, the High Court was justified in setting aside condition (iii) of the Chief Secretary's order dated 21.06.2022, which sought to reimpose the use restriction.”
Further, the bench rejected the contention that the land could not have been alienated, the Court said the alternative land was allotted in lieu of the predecessors-in-interest's own acquired land. “It is trite law that a person possessing title over a property has the absolute right of transferring and alienating the same to a third person,” it observed.
Perusing the 2005 sale deed, the Court noted that it effected “not only an effective transfer of the allotted land but also an assignment of the right to receive any other land given by the Housing Board in lieu of the above land,” and any subsequent land allotted in lieu would therefore vest in Gaursons.
With respect to the 2016 Exchange Deed, it observed that the deed was “a fresh registered instrument, executed with the no-objection of the State Government, in respect of a different plot in a different scheme,” and described the plot as a residential freehold plot and expressly permits residential construction.
The bench also noted that Clause 13 of the 2016 deed imported only the stipulation that no value or consideration is payable, as recorded in the 1995 order. “The parties thus chose which terms of the compromise would govern the substituted land. Binding the first respondent to the stipulations of the 2004 Exchange Deed is, therefore, not sustainable,” it held.
To decide on the Chief Secretary's direction to allot the land at the current bulk sale rate, the Court relied on Clause 13 of the 2016 Exchange Deed. It also relied on the lower circle rates in the Siddharth Vihar Scheme and the Rs 32.45 crore already paid as conversion charges, and observed that these factors left no ground for the Housing Board to demand anything more from Gaursons.
The bench noted that the Housing Board had retained and developed the acquired land, which is of greater value than the land it gave in exchange, without paying any compensation to the predecessors-in-interest. “It cannot, in these circumstances, demand a further price from the first respondent for the substituted land,” the Court held, and found no reason to interfere with the High Court's setting aside the condition.
With regards to the government's reliance on the SIT report to allege collusion between Housing Board officials and Gaursons, the Court noted that Gaursons had objected to the institution and the report of the SIT.
In the light of aforesaid, the Supreme Court dismissed the plea and upheld the Allahabad High Court's order.
“Having considered the matter in detail, we are of the opinion that there is no merit in these appeals. Civil Appeal Nos. 9025 of 2026, 9026 of 2026 and 9027-9028 of 2026 filed against the judgment and order in Writ-C No. 19048 of 2022 and Writ-C No. 29931 of 2022 dated 07.02.2023 are therefore dismissed. In these circumstances, the two months' time granted by the High Court to the State of Uttar Pradesh for allotment of the 450 EWS/LIG Flats is extended by three months from the date of our judgment and order. Parties shall bear their own costs.”
Appearances:
For Appellants: Mr. R. Venkataramani, Attorney General for India; Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G.; Mr. Rana Mukherjee, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Kamlendra Mishra, AOR; Mr. Ruchir Ranjan Rai, Adv.; Mr. Rajeev Kumar Dubey, Adv.; Mr. Ashiwan Mishra, Adv.; Mr. Kartikay Aggarwal, Adv.; Ms. Vaidruti Mishra, Adv.; Ms. Aditi Mishra, Adv.; Ms. Nancy Singla, Adv.; Mr. Suraj, Adv.; Mr. Anupam, Adv.; Mr. P. N. Misra, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Abhishek Kumar Singh, AOR; Mr. Abhinav Jaganathan, Adv.; Ms. Anamika Yadav, Adv.; Mr. Harsh V. Singh, Adv.; Mr. Kartik Arora, Adv.; Ms. Pallavi Singh, Adv.
For Respondents: Mr. Anand Shankar Jha, AOR; Dr. Veenu Singhal, Adv.; Mr. Sachin Mintri, Adv.; Mr. Parvez Rahman, Adv.; Mr. Shubhank Sharma, Adv.; Mr. Kamlendra Mishra, AOR; Mr. Abhishek Kumar Singh, AOR