The Supreme Court on Tuesday (November 17) heard the arguments made by the State of Tamil Nadu seeking a stay of the Madras High Court's direction allowing the lighting of the traditional temple lamp atop a stone pillar near the Dargah at the Thiruparankudram hill in Madurai district.

The State sought urgent interim relief, pointing out that the Kartigai Deepam of the Vrishchikam month falls on November 24, and the lamp will have to be lit at the disputed site on that day if the High Court's direction is not stayed.

A bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul Pancholi heard the arguments for over 1.5 hours this afternoon.

Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta, for the State of Tamil Nadu, stated that there was no such prevailing custom to light the lamp at the Deepathoon.  He took the bench through previous judgments of the High Court which rejected the plea to light a lamp at the disputed location. The priests have affirmed that as per Agamas, the lamp can be lit at the place where it was being traditionally lit at the place near Uchi Pillaiyar Temple, and there was no custom to light the lamp at the Deepathoon near the Dargah. Hence, no mandamus can be issued since there is no right established.

"If the temple says this is the practice, normally the Courts will not interfere," Gupta said.

Gupta argued that the petitioners have not discharged the burden of proving the custom of lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon.  

"One of the things stated in the judgment is, generally in Tamil Nadu, temple lamp is lit on the hilltop. That is not proof of custom. The proof of custom is what the sthanikars have said, regarding the lighting of deepam at Uchi Pillaiyar Temple," he submitted.

Senior Advocate Shekhar Naphade, for the HR&CE Commissioner, submitted, "If some practice has been going on for 100 years, why change it?" Naphade submitted that the High Court's observation was that the lamp must be lit at the hilltop. But the top of the hill is the Dargah, and on that count, the High Court is wrong, Naphade submitted.

He added that the reasonable course would be to preserve the status quo which had been continuing for years while the appeal is pending in the Supreme Court.

TN Additional Advocate General Prashanto Chandra Sen supplemented the arguments of Gupta and Naphade. He highlighted that previous High Court judgments have rejected the prayer for lighting the lamp at the Deepathon, and hence, the latest petition was hit by the principle of res judicata. Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan also made supporting submissions on behalf of the District Collector.

Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi for the Sikandar Badhusah Dharga made brief submissions that the High Court has created a new practice.

The bench will continue the hearing tomorrow at 2 PM.

The Special Leave Petition has been filed against the order passed by a division bench of the Madras High Court (Madurai Bench) on January 6, which upheld an order passed by a single bench in December last year allowing the lighting of the 'Karthigai Deepam' at the spot.

The High Court's order was passed in writ petitions filed by individuals who sought the right to light a lamp at the 'Deepa Thoon' (stone lamp pillar) atop the Thirupparankundram hills. The spot is located about 50 meters away from a Dargah on the hill. The State HR&CE Department, which manages the Lord Subramaniya temple at the bottom of the hill, opposed the plea, contending that there was no custom of lighting the lamp at the Deepa Thoon, as it was customarily lit at another spot.

Justice GR Swaminathan of the High Court allowed the writ petition, observing that the rights of the Dargah were not affected by the act, and stopping the lamp-lighting would violate the rights of the devotees. The refusal of the State administration to allow the lamp-lighting led to contempt proceedings, where Justice Swaminathan passed orders to execute the act with the protection of CISF forces. The division bench upheld the orders passed by Justice Swaminathan in contempt proceedings. Challenging the dismissal of the contempt proceedings, the State had filed an SLP in December last year, but the same never got listed in the Supreme Court.

In January, a division bench upheld the original orders passed by Justice Swaminathan in the writ petitions, holding that the lighting of the lamp will not cause any law and order problem. The division bench held that the temple management has the duty to protect the traditions. The division bench also rejected the argument of the State that the 'deepa thoon' was a survey stone erected by the British rulers.

 


Tags: