Reel Makers Not Entitled To Journalistic Protection During Protests, Delhi Police To Supreme Court
| It has to be determined if reel-makers and content-creators can be elevated to the status of journalists, the Delhi police said.
The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that its order directing protection of journalists covering the anti-Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) protests was not intended to cover "so-called reel makers and social media influencers".
In a counter-affidavit filed before the Supreme Court, the Delhi Police said that some participants in the "illegal protests" were content creators making YouTube reels while carrying cameras and microphones, making it difficult for police personnel to distinguish between genuine journalists and reel-makers on the ground.
The police said that it had to be determined whether "reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters", adding that the distinction was highlighted only to explain the practical difficulties faced by police personnel while managing protests.
Clarifying that it did not intend to obstruct content creators from pursuing their activities, the Delhi Police said that the guidelines for journalists covering protests were meant to distinguish professional journalists and reporters from persons carrying cameras and microphones for other purposes, including commercial exploitation of content.
The affidavit was filed by Joint Commissioner of Police Surrender Kumar on behalf of the Delhi Police responding to the petitions filed by the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and the Kerala Union of Working Journalists concerning alleged police misconduct against journalists covering the protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.
The police referred to the Supreme Court's order dated October 11, 2026, which recorded the assurance given by the Solicitor General that lawyers, journalists and other professionals would not be hindered in discharging their professional duties.
It submitted that the direction was intended to protect journalists in the discharge of their professional duties and was not meant to exempt reel-makers, social media influencers or unruly elements from the general law or lawful directions of law enforcement agencies at the site of a prohibited assembly.
The affidavit further stated that the police had not placed any restriction on the right of citizens to report or disseminate information, nor had anyone been proceeded against merely for lacking press accreditation or an identity card.
The police maintained that the restrictions imposed at the protest sites were uniformly applicable to all persons, irrespective of whether they identified themselves as journalists.
Guidelines for journalists
The Delhi Police also defended its October 5 advisory prescribing guidelines for journalists covering protests. The advisory asks journalists to carry valid identity cards issued by their respective organisations or valid accreditation cards issued by the Press Information Bureau (PIB) or the Directorate of Information and Publicity (DIP).
It also advises journalists to keep their identification cards visibly displayed, ensure that their presence and activities do not obstruct police operations, and maintain a reasonable and safe distance while covering tense situations.
The police said the advisory was facilitative and precautionary in nature and was intended to help police personnel identify genuine journalists and ensure their safety while discharging professional duties.
It clarified that the absence of formal PIB accreditation would not, by itself, prevent journalists from being identified and facilitated in performing their professional duties. An identity card issued by the journalist's employer or organisation was also accepted as an alternative means of identification.
The affidavit also relied on the Central Media Accreditation Guidelines, 2022, which define a working journalist based on objective criteria, including journalism being the person's principal vocation and their employment in or association with a recognised news establishment.
It further referred to the Press Council of India's October 15 guidelines for journalists covering protests and demonstrations, which prescribe professional conduct, identification requirements, crowd safety measures and responsible reporting.
Police deny obstructing journalists
Denying allegations of deliberate obstruction of journalists, the Delhi Police said that no concerted action was taken to prevent journalists from discharging their professional duties.
It stated that any journalist inadvertently removed from a protest site due to mistaken identity was released immediately upon verification of their credentials.
The police also said that several videos of the protests had been freely circulated on social media and broadcast by national and international media organisations, contradicting the allegation that journalists were prevented from witnessing and reporting the events.
Regarding complaints made by women journalists following the October 3 protests near Jantar Mantar, the police said four complaints were received and transferred to the Crime Branch for inquiry. It claimed that the complaints had subsequently been examined and that the relevant CCTV footage did not corroborate the specific allegations of sexual harassment.
The police also denied seizing any media equipment belonging to journalists.