Shiv Sena Dispute | Dissent Not Defection; Skipping Party Meeting Doesn't Mean Giving Up Membership : Eknath Shinde to Supreme Court
In the Shiv Sena dispute, Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta, for Eknath Shinde, argued before the Supreme Court yesterday that there can't be a disqualification for not attending a meeting of a legislative party, as it cannot be regarded as voluntarily giving up of membership of a political party in terms of the Tenth Schedule.
He argued that the disqualification petitions filed by Shiv Sena UBT member Sunil Prabhu against the members of the Eknath Shinde faction say they incurred disqualification for not attending a "legislative party meeting" on June 21, 2022. Mehta explained that this can't lead to disqualification for the purpose of Article 2(1)(a) of the Tenth Schedule because it requires giving up membership of a political party.
"By not attending legislative party meeting, how have I given up membership of the political party?" he said.
The arguments were made before a bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana in a plea filed by Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray's faction challenging the Maharashtra Speaker's refusal to disqualify MLAs of the Eknath Shinde faction under the 10th Schedule.
Another petition, filed by Uddhav Thackeray, was also listed before the bench, which challenges the ECI decision that recognised the Eknath Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and allowed them to use the 'bow and arrow' symbol.
Mehta said: "Whether the petitioners proved disqualification? Disqualification occurs on voluntarily giving up membership of a political party, but just see the pleadings in the disqualification petition. They[petitioners] have mentioned that the respondent has given up the membership of the Shiv Sena legislative party, and has remained absent from the meetings despite being fully aware of its importance in the backdrop of the Maharashtra Legislative Council elections. Disqualification notices also mention this."
He added that the disqualification notices are issued on the letterhead of the Shiv Sena Legislative Office(Shiv Sena Vidhan Manal Paksh) signed by Sunil Prabhu.
Mehta further alleged that a WhatsApp text was sent on June 21 at 12:31 PM to the Personal Assistant of Eknath Shinde when the meeting had begun at 12:30. He stated that this was merely a call for a meeting by Sunil Prabhu, which is not the same as a whip and no resolution was passed as alleged. Further, he pointed out that the meeting had no agenda and Sunil Prabhu in cross-examination, himself accepted that the meeting was called as the Eknath Shinde faction was not reachable and it was an attempt at "reconciliation".
Adding to this, he stated that their reliance on an "attendance register" as evidence that the Shinde faction defied the party's whip is self-contradictory because first they claim that the faction went against the party's whip by not attending the meeting. At the same time, they rely on the attendance register to argue that the faction members had, in fact, signed the register.
He called the signatures on the attendance register 'fabricated'.
"The fabrication is apparent from their assertions; while they rely on signatures of members, they themselves have arraigned them in the disqualification. This is perjury!," he submitted.
Mehta submitted that the attendance register was held unreliable by the Speaker. He added that another "glaring discrepancy" is that signatures of two persons were forged and inserted.
"Significantly, Sunil Prabhu didn't deny the discrepancy and said it's actually a matter of record."
In sum and substance, Mehta said: "Our idea is, dissent is not defection as this is not the purport of the Tenth Schedule."
Arguments will continue today.