The Supreme Court on Monday (November 16) set aside the removal from service of a Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) Constable who had overstayed his leave by 99 days, holding that the penalty of removal was “grossly disproportionate” and that the rejection of his medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises.

A bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh held so while allowing the appeal against a Patna High Court (Division Bench) judgment, which had restored the removal order after a Single Judge had quashed it. The Supreme Court has now directed reinstatement with immediate effect, along with 50% of the back wages and all other consequential benefits.

The appellant was granted casual leave from September 21, 2000 to October 12, 2000 on the ground of his wife's illness, and was to rejoin on October 13, 2000. However, he failed to do so and did not respond to two registered letters directing him to report for duty. He finally reported on January 19, 2001, overstaying the sanctioned leave by 99 days.

In an application dated January 22, 2001, he explained that he had himself fallen ill on October 9, 2000 at his village and had been treated for infective hepatitis by a Medical Officer. He relied on medical prescriptions, pathological reports, receipts for medicines and a certificate declaring him fit for duty on January 13, 2001. He also said that his illness, the absence of postal facilities in his village and his wife's inability to read or write had prevented him from responding to the letters.

However, a memorandum of charges alleged unauthorised absence for 99 days and disobedience of orders in not responding to the two letters. The Enquiry Officer held both charges proved on and the medical documents were rejected because they did not bear an indoor or outdoor patient number, the treatment appeared to have been obtained privately, and the prescriptions and medicine bills appeared to have been written with the same pen, which the Enquiry Officer inferred were prepared on the same day and were fabricated. Thereafter, the Commandant imposed the penalty of removal from service in March 2001. The departmental appeal and revision were rejected in 2002 and 2004 respectively.

A Single Judge of the Patna High Court allowed the appellant's writ petition holding that the reasons for rejecting the medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises, and directed the respondents to accept his joining. In a Letters Patent Appeal, the Division Bench reversed the Single Bench's finding, holding that it had exceeded the limits of judicial review by reappreciating the evidence. It observed that once the absence was held to be unauthorised, the plea of illness failed, that past conduct was relevant to the quantum of punishment, and that discipline had to be maintained in a uniformed force deployed in a sensitive area (Anantnag, Jammu & Kashmir).

Aggrieved by the Division Bench's finding, the appellant approached the Supreme Court.

Before the Supreme Court, the appellant argued that the medical documents could not have been treated as fabricated merely because of the pen or ink used or the absence of a hospital registration number, without examining the treating doctor or otherwise verifying them. It was also argued that the earlier periods of overstay had already been dealt with, that removal was disproportionate, and that the enquiry did not comply with Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF Rules, 1955.

Per contra, the Union government (respondents) submitted that the appellant was a member of a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, and remained absent for 99 days without permission and ignored two directions to report. Reliance was placed on earlier overstays of 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in 1999, to argue that the Single Judge had impermissibly substituted his own assessment of the evidence.

The Supreme Court framed the question as whether the Division Bench was justified in setting aside the Single Judge's order and restoring the penalty of removal. Relying on State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors v S Sree Rama Rao and BC Chaturvedi v Union of India & Ors, it recalled the limits of judicial review in disciplinary matters.

Quoting Sree Rama Rao, the bench noted that a High Court may interfere where the conclusion “on the very face of it is so wholly arbitrary and capricious that no reasonable person could ever have arrived at that conclusion.” Referring to Chaturvedi, the bench noted that “if the punishment imposed by the disciplinary authority or the appellate authority shocks the conscience of the High Court/Tribunal, it would appropriately mould the relief, either directing the disciplinary/appellate authority to reconsider the penalty imposed, or to shorten the litigation, it may itself, in exceptional and rare cases, impose appropriate punishment with cogent reasons in support thereof.”

Considering the above, the bench observed as follows with regards to unauthorised absence and wilful absence:

“Tested on the aforesaid principles, we are of the considered view that the Division Bench erroneously set aside the order passed by the Single Judge. Absence from duty without prior permission may constitute unauthorised absence; however, unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous. The circumstances in which an employee remained absent, the explanation furnished, and the material supporting that explanation must be considered before determining the nature and gravity of the misconduct. Illness or other circumstances beyond an employee's control may be relevant to that determination, though they do not, by themselves, automatically excuse the entire period of absence.”

The bench further noted that the Enquiry Officer had disregarded the documents on the ground that certain entries appeared to have been made with the same pen and that they bore no outpatient department number.

“No verification from the treating doctor, the medical establishment or the pharmacy supported that inference. Similarity in the writing or ink, without material connecting it to fabrication, could not reasonably sustain the conclusion drawn in the present case,” the bench observed.

Further, the Court observed that the absence of an indoor or outdoor patient number, and the fact that the doctor appeared to have treated the appellant privately while affixing his official seal to the fitness certificate, could call for clarification. However, this did not “establish either that no treatment had been received or that the documents were forged. The learned Single Judge, therefore, rightly held that the rejection of the medical documents rested on conjectures and surmises.”

The bench acknowledged that the appellant was a member of a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, and that compliance with orders and timely reporting for duty are essential obligations of such service. However, it held as follows:

“However, the punishment imposed must satisfy the requirement of proportionality. In the present case, the punishment of removal from service for overstaying the period of 99 days is unduly harsh considering the relevant circumstances. Even after taking into account the earlier periods of overstay and the Appellant's failure to maintain communication, we are satisfied that the penalty of removal from service, in these particular circumstances, is grossly disproportionate in the facts of this case.”

In the light of aforesaid, the Supreme Court set aside the Patna High Court (Division Bench) judgment and restored the Single Judge order. It also directed the respondents to reinstate the appellant with immediate effect with a direction to pay him 50% of the back wages for the period he was removed from service till his reinstatement.

“In the result, the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 05.05.2010 passed by the High Court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 921 of 2007 is set aside, and the order dated 13.04.2007 passed by the learned Single Judge in CWJC No. 5308 of 2004 is restored. The respondents are directed to reinstate the appellant with immediate effect with a direction to pay him 50% of the back wages for the period he was removed from service till his reinstatement. He will be entitled for all other consequential benefits.”

Appearances:

For Appellant: Ms. Prerna Singh, AOR; Mr. Sushansu, Adv.; Mr. Aakash Kumar, Adv.

For Respondents: Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, A.S.G.; Mr. Nachiketa Joshi, Sr. Adv.; Dr. N. Visakamurthy, AOR; Mr. Yashraj Bundela, Adv.; Mr. Amit Sharma-ii, Adv.; Mr. Amrish Kumar, AOR; Mr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Adv.; Mr. Arvind Kumar Sharma, AOR

Tags: