New House Saddled With ₹2.1 Lakh Joint Family Electricity Dues; Kupwara Consumer Commission Quashes Bill
The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Kupwara, comprising President Peerzada Qousar Hussain and Member Nyla Yaseen, has quashed an electricity bill of ₹2,10,934 issued to a consumer after outstanding dues relating to his jointly owned family house were carried forward to his newly constructed separate house. The Commission held that the electricity department's failure to rectify the billing particulars amounted to deficiency in service.
Facts
The complainant, Ghulam Nabi Magray, approached the Commission alleging that the Executive Engineer of KPDCL, Division Handwara, had arbitrarily transferred outstanding electricity dues relating to his ancestral joint-family house to his newly constructed separate house.
According to the complainant, he had previously lived in a joint family with his three brothers, and the electricity connection for the joint-family house was registered in his name as he was the head of the family. Subsequently, he constructed a separate house and started residing there.
He alleged that instead of issuing a fresh independent electricity bill for the newly constructed house, the electricity department carried forward the outstanding dues of the joint-family house to his new premises.
The complainant further submitted that the department continued generating electricity bills for the new house despite the absence of basic electricity infrastructure, including electric poles and low-tension (LT) distribution lines near the premises.
The outstanding amount had accumulated to ₹2,10,934 by March 2025. Despite repeatedly approaching the department seeking correction of the bills, no effective action was taken, compelling him to approach the Consumer Commission.
The opposite party appeared before the Commission through its counsel but failed to file its written version within the prescribed period. Consequently, its right to file the written version was closed.
Commission's Observations
After hearing the parties and examining the documents and evidence on record, the Commission observed that the complainant had approached the electricity department seeking rectification of the bills issued in his name against the previously existing jointly owned family house.
It noted that although the complainant had approached the Deputy Commissioner, Kupwara, in 2018, following which a departmental team inspected the premises and disconnected the electricity connection, bills continued to be generated in his name, resulting in the accumulation of substantial dues.
The Commission observed that the electricity department was under an obligation to rectify the billing particulars and issue bills in the name of the proper subscriber of the jointly owned house rather than continuing to raise bills in the complainant's name.
It further held that the department's failure to correct the billing details had resulted in the accumulation of dues and caused inconvenience to the complainant.
"Not rectifying the particulars of the electricity bills has accumulated the amount and has admittedly caused inconvenience to the complainant. Such inaction of the OP amounts to deficiency in service on the part of the OP," the Commission observed.
Decision
Partly allowing the complaint, the Commission quashed the electricity bill of ₹2,10,934 issued in the complainant's name under Consumer ID No. 0214010006915.
It directed the electricity department to issue a fresh electricity bill in the complainant's name for the newly constructed house, provided that the premises had an electricity connection.
However, the Commission clarified that the complainant would remain liable to pay the outstanding dues relating to the jointly owned family house.
The Commission also directed KPDCL to pay ₹10,000 to the complainant towards litigation charges within four weeks from the date of service of a copy of the order.