Click the Play button to listen to article

The Calcutta High Court recently declined to issue further directions on a plea seeking an independent and impartial investigation into the death of a Class 12 student who allegedly suffered fatal injuries after drinking scalding hot tea at his school's canteen.

Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya noted that the police had already completed their investigation and filed a chargesheet in the matter. The Court, however, clarified that the deceased student's father was at liberty to approach the jurisdictional magistrate seeking further investigation under Section 193(9) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, if dissatisfied with the investigation.

The petition was filed by Manaranjan Mahata, father of the deceased student, who was studying at a Ramakrishna Mission-run school in Narendrapur, Kolkata.

The student died on June 30, 2026, after allegedly consuming extremely hot tea at the school's canteen.

The father had sought directions for an impartial and transparent investigation into the circumstances surrounding his son's death. He had also sought the appointment of a retired judge to monitor the investigation.

According to the petition, the school authorities were aware that the student had started showing signs of illness shortly after consuming the hot tea. However, the father was allegedly informed about the incident several hours later, by which time his son's condition had deteriorated considerably.

It was further alleged that the school authorities failed to arrange timely medical assistance for the student. The petition also raised concerns regarding the preservation of CCTV footage recording the events leading up to the incident.

The father's counsel submitted that the Ramakrishna Mission authorities were asked to take the student to the hospital but refused to do so despite having transportation facilities.

The Mission's counsel denied the allegations, contending that the student was declared dead only upon reaching the hospital and that the school could not be held responsible since the death did not take place within its premises.

Justice Bhattacharyya questioned the institution's response to the incident.

"But the incident of having the breakfast was within the school premises and after examining the son of the petitioner, what steps did your institution take?" the Court asked.

The judge further questioned why the school authorities had waited for the father to arrive instead of immediately sending the student to a hospital.

"Why did the institution wait till the father came? ... Why was he not sent directly to the hospital for immediate treatment?" the Court asked.

The State government, meanwhile, assured the Court that the relevant CCTV footage had been preserved.

Taking note of the fact that the police had already filed a chargesheet dated September 9, 2026, following the investigation, the Court declined to issue further directions.

The Court observed:  "Chargesheet dated 9th September, 2026 is filed on concluding investigation. If petitioner (the father) is dissatisfied with the manner of investigation and chargesheet filed, on conclusion of such investigation, in that event, he has remedy under Section 193 (9) of the BNSS, 2023 by approaching jurisdictional magistrate seeking further investigation."

The Court accordingly closed the plea while preserving the father's liberty to pursue the statutory remedy for further investigation.

Tags: