The Calcutta High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against residents of a housing complex accused of forgery, cheating and criminal breach of trust over the formation of a cultural committee and collection of funds for organising Durga Puja and other social events.

Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das held that the investigating agency had failed to collect any material to prima facie establish the allegations against the petitioners, including the creation of forged documents or wrongful gain through the collection of subscriptions.

The Court observed that no documents had been seized during the investigation to establish that the petitioners had created any false document to give the impression that they were authorised to collect funds from the residents.

"It is glaringly visible in the instant case that the investigating authority has failed to collect enough materials to prima facie establish the ingredients to constitute the offences under which the charge sheet has been submitted," the Court observed.

The Court further held that allowing the criminal proceedings to continue, despite the absence of materials establishing the essential ingredients of the alleged offences, would amount to an abuse of the process of law.

The petitioners had approached the High Court seeking quashing of the criminal proceedings arising out of Rajarhat Police Station Case No. 295 of 2024, registered under Sections 406, 419, 420, 465 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code.

**Background**

The dispute arose out of the formation of a cultural committee by residents of a housing complex for organising Durga Puja in 2023 and other social and religious events.

According to the materials referred to by the Court, after obtaining preliminary approval to convene a meeting, a general meeting of the residents was held, where it was unanimously decided to form the cultural committee. The committee was constituted to organise Durga Puja and other social events, with its tenure ending on March 31, 2024.

The promoter/developer had also issued a no-objection certificate through email authorising the petitioners to conduct the annual Puja and other festivals.

However, one of the residents subsequently lodged a complaint alleging offences relating to the formation of the committee and collection of funds.

The petitioners contended that the criminal proceedings were an outcome of a personal dispute and pointed out that the complainant had not contributed any amount towards the committee.

**Court's Findings**

Examining the allegations, the Court noted that the investigating officer had not seized any document, physical or electronic, to prima facie establish that the petitioners had manufactured a false document with the intention of committing forgery.

It also found that the investigating agency had not recorded the statement of the promoter/developer, whose alleged no-objection certificate was questioned by the complainant. Further, no documents were collected from the bank to establish the alleged siphoning of funds contributed by the residents.

The investigating officer had also neither collected the audit report nor interrogated the auditor appointed by the committee, despite allegations of misappropriation of funds.

The Court noted that the complainant himself had not paid any subscription to the committee. Therefore, the essential ingredients of wrongful loss required to attract the offences of cheating under Sections 419 and 420 IPC were not established.

Similarly, the Court found no material to establish that any property had been entrusted to the petitioners by the complainant and subsequently dishonestly misappropriated by them to constitute criminal breach of trust.

Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in *Mohammed Ibrahim v. State of Bihar*, the Court reiterated that the condition precedent for offences under Sections 467 and 471 IPC is the commission of forgery, which in turn requires the making of a false document. It noted that the investigation had not brought on record any such document.

The Court also took note of the fact that the petitioners and other residents had lodged a complaint against the opposite party on March 18, 2024, alleging threats and criminal intimidation. The complaint had referred to an alleged threat by the complainant to lodge an FIR unless an unconditional apology was tendered.

In these circumstances, the Court observed that the possibility of the criminal complaint being a counterblast to the earlier complaint could not be ruled out.

**Investigation Failed To Collect Basic Materials, Court Says**

The Court distinguished the present case from decisions where the Supreme Court had cautioned High Courts against quashing criminal proceedings at the threshold when serious triable allegations were supported by materials collected during investigation.

Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in *Rocky v. State of Telangana*, the Court reiterated that the power under Section 482 CrPC must be exercised sparingly and that disputed questions of fact ordinarily should not be examined at the pre-trial stage.

However, it found that the present case was distinguishable as the investigating agency had failed to collect even the basic materials necessary to substantiate the allegations.

Relying on the principles laid down in *State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal*, the Court held that the allegations in the complaint did not disclose the ingredients of the offences alleged against the petitioners.

The Court also referred to the Supreme Court's observations in *Sharif Ahmed v. State of Uttar Pradesh*, emphasising that a chargesheet must clearly disclose the crime allegedly committed by each accused and the material evidence available against them.

It noted that apart from the complainant and another person, no other residents had been cited as witnesses. The developer, whose no-objection certificate was allegedly disputed, had also not been examined.

Further, neither the auditor nor any relevant documents from the auditor's office had been brought on record despite the allegation of siphoning of funds.

Concluding that the chargesheet was not legally sustainable and that no case had been made out to put the petitioners on trial, the Court allowed the revisional application.

Accordingly, the entire criminal proceedings arising out of Rajarhat Police Station Case No. 295 of 2024, pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate at Barasat, North 24 Parganas, under Sections 406, 419, 420, 465 and 120B IPC, were quashed against the petitioners.