Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Calcutta High Court has quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 498A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code against a husband, observing that merely not answering his wife's phone calls, without more, would not constitute cruelty under Section 498A IPC.Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta held that the allegations of physical and mental torture against the husband were vague and general, as the...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Calcutta High Court has quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 498A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code against a husband, observing that merely not answering his wife's phone calls, without more, would not constitute cruelty under Section 498A IPC.

Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta held that the allegations of physical and mental torture against the husband were vague and general, as the complainant had not specified any date, time, place or manner of the alleged acts of cruelty. The Court further observed that the complaint did not disclose any dowry-related harassment or conduct of such a nature as was likely to drive the wife to commit suicide or cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health.

"The offence, therefore, requires the complainant to be a married woman, subjected to cruelty by her husband or his relatives, and that such cruelty shall fall within clauses (a) or (b) of the Explanation," the Court observed.

The Court was hearing a criminal revision petition filed by the husband seeking quashing of the proceedings arising out of a complaint lodged by his wife at Bagnan Police Station in December 2020.

The wife had alleged that she was subjected to physical and mental torture by her husband and in-laws after their marriage in March 2017. She had also alleged that her mother-in-law and sister-in-law compelled her to perform household chores, prevented her from accessing documents required to obtain a ration card for her minor son and repeatedly locked her out of her matrimonial home.

The husband, however, contended that he was pursuing his PhD studies in Haridwar and was not residing with his wife during the relevant period. He argued that the principal allegation against him was that he failed to answer his wife's phone calls while staying outside West Bengal.

He further pointed out that proceedings against his mother and sister, who were also accused in the case, had already been quashed by coordinate Benches of the High Court after the allegations against them were found to be vague and omnibus in nature.

The State opposed the quashing petition, submitting that statements of witnesses had been recorded during the investigation and the materials collected disclosed a prima facie case. It argued that the petitioner should face trial to enable the victim and other witnesses to establish the allegations.

The Court, however, found that the specific grievance against the husband was that he did not answer his wife's calls or call her back to ascertain the situation at home.

"The sole specific grievance against the petitioner was that he did not answer her calls. The Court finds that this does not amount to cruelty," the judgment recorded.

Explaining its reasoning, the Court observed that the complaint did not specify the number of calls made, the dates on which they were made or whether the wife was in any danger or required urgent assistance at the relevant time.

It further noted that the husband was pursuing higher studies outside West Bengal and was not ordinarily present at the matrimonial home. A student could be attending classes, examinations or otherwise engaged when a call was made, the Court observed.

"A call left unreceived is, by itself, an omission and not an act of wilful conduct," the Court held.

The Bench further observed that even if the husband's calls went unanswered on every occasion, such conduct might cause marital discontent but could not be said to be of a nature likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health.

The Court also noted that the complaint did not disclose any unlawful demand for dowry or property, thereby ruling out the applicability of clause (b) of the Explanation to Section 498A IPC.

It added that the invocation of Section 34 IPC was also without foundation, as the husband was not present when the alleged quarrels with the mother-in-law and sister-in-law took place and no act on his part in aid of those alleged incidents had been described.

The Court clarified that it was not relying on the husband's contention that the FIR was registered without a preliminary inquiry. Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh, the Court observed that although a preliminary inquiry is permissible in certain categories of cases, including matrimonial disputes, the absence of such an inquiry does not by itself render an FIR invalid

Tags: