Citing Health Risks From Delhi Air Pollution, High Court Permits Elderly Witnesses Living Abroad To Record Evidence Virtually
The Delhi High Court has allowed two senior citizens residing in the United Kingdom and the United States of America to record their evidence through video conferencing in a pending probate case, after they expressed concerns regarding their health due to the air pollution conditions ordinarily prevailing in Delhi-NCR during the winter months.
Justice Vinod Kumar allowed an application filed by the two individuals, aged 79 and 77 years respectively, seeking permission to record their evidence through video conferencing instead of travelling to India during the proposed period of examination.
The individuals had submitted that their evidence was likely to be recorded between October and January 2027, when Delhi-NCR ordinarily experiences severe air pollution. They contended that prolonged exposure to such conditions could pose health risks as they were not accustomed to the prevailing climatic conditions in Delhi during this period.
The application was filed in a petition filed under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, seeking grant of probate in respect of an alleged Will dated December 18, 2010, executed by one late Surender Mohan Khanna.
Khanna's counsel opposed the application, raising concerns about the possibility of witnesses being tutored during remote examination, the availability of relevant documents at the remote locations, procedure for obtaining signatures on recorded statements and the time difference between India and the countries where the respondents reside.
It was also argued that permitting examination through video conferencing would lead to further delay in the proceedings.
Rejecting these objections, the Court observed that the respondents' age, their residence outside India, the inconvenience associated with international travel and the health concerns arising from Delhi's air pollution conditions during the proposed period of examination were relevant considerations in determining the appropriate mode of recording their evidence.
“The request, however, must be considered in conjunction with the procedural safeguards necessary to ensure that the evidence is recorded fairly and that the petitioner is afforded an effective opportunity to test the testimony of the applicants,” the Court added.
It referred to Rules 10, 13 and 14 of the Delhi High Court Electronic Evidence and Video Conferencing Rules, 2025, which provide safeguards against tutoring of witnesses, prescribe procedures for making relevant documents available at remote locations and regulate the exhibition of documents during examination.
The Court noted that Rule 10 contains safeguards to ensure that a witness examined at a remote location is not prompted, tutored, coaxed, induced or coerced by any person. It also noted that the provision provides for the transmission of electronic copies of relevant documents to the coordinator at the remote point, subject to the Court's permission.
The Court also took note of Rule 14 which prescribes the procedure for exhibiting or showing documents to a witness at the remote location, while Rule 13 provides a mechanism for obtaining signatures on the transcript of evidence recorded through video conferencing.
The Court also observed that the difference in time zones between India and the countries concerned did not constitute an insurmountable impediment.
“The learned Local Commissioner can settle the dates and timings in consultation with the parties and the concerned coordinators, keeping in view the local time at each remote point and the requirement of conducting the proceedings in an orderly manner,” the Court said.
Further, Justice Kumar noted that permitting the respondents to depose through video conferencing would avoid the need to defer their examination until their proposed physical visit to India in February or March 2027.
“There can be no disagreement on this issue that recording evidence through video conferencing must not result in any dilution of the procedural safeguards applicable to examination and cross-examination,” the Court observed.
It added that Khanna would retain a full and effective opportunity to cross-examine both respondents, including with reference to documents relevant to their testimony.
Accordingly, the Court designated the Delhi High Court premises as the 'Court Point' for conducting the cross-examination of respondent No. 2, Virendar Mohan Khanna, and respondent No. 5, Savita Gambhir.
The High Commission of India in London was designated as the 'Remote Point' for respondent No. 2, while the Consulate General of India in New York was designated as the 'Remote Point' for respondent No. 5.
The Court directed the two respondents to pay a composite fee of Rs. 1 lakh towards the services of the IT officer, to be shared equally between them.
Further, officials from the High Commission of India in London and the Consulate General of India in New York were directed to remain present at the respective remote points during the examination.
The Court directed the Local Commissioner, parties and concerned coordinators to ensure strict compliance with the provisions governing identification of witnesses, prevention of tutoring, presentation and exhibition of documents, administration of oath, recording of evidence, signing of transcripts and preservation of the electronic record.