Criminal Courts Must Pronounce Orders Within 15 Days Of Arguments On Miscellaneous Applications: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has directed criminal courts in the national capital to pronounce orders on miscellaneous applications within 15 days of conclusion of arguments.
Justice Girish Kathpalia observed that keeping matters undecided for an unreasonable period after hearing arguments erodes public confidence in the justice delivery system.
The Court further clarified that final judgments in criminal cases should ordinarily be pronounced within 30 days, extendable up to 45 days for reasons to be recorded in writing, in terms of Section 258(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
Justice Kathpalia issued the directions while ordering a trial court to decide an application filed under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) within 15 days.
The Court was hearing a petition filed by one Karan Kapoor, who sought directions for expeditious disposal of his pending application before the trial court.
Kapoor's counsel submitted that arguments on the application had been advanced thrice and the matter had repeatedly been listed for orders. Although arguments were last heard on October 31, the trial court had listed the matter for orders on January 28, 2027.
Taking note of the repeated adjournments, the Court observed that the matter did not involve delay attributable to the pendency of a trial, such as the non-availability of witnesses, prosecutors or forensic reports. Rather, arguments on a miscellaneous application had been heard repeatedly, with the matter being listed for orders on several occasions.
Justice Kathpalia further observed that the reference to the possibility of “clarifications” in the trial court's ordersheets did not appear convincing and seemed to have been used mechanically to justify the delay in pronouncing the order.
The Court noted that arguments had earlier been heard on May 20, and the matter was adjourned to July 14, for orders or clarifications. Thereafter, the court was not held on six consecutive dates, and arguments were eventually heard for the third time on October 31.
“After conclusion of arguments, the orders should be pronounced as soon as possible, so that while dictating the order, the arguments raised are fresh in the mind of the judge,” the Court observed.
It added that posting matters on unjustifiably long dates after hearing arguments itself gives rise to the need for obtaining clarifications.
The Court acknowledged that criminal procedural law does not prescribe a specific timeline for passing orders on miscellaneous applications. However, it said that guidance could be drawn from Section 258(1) BNSS, which provides that a Sessions Court should deliver its judgment as soon as possible and within 30 days of conclusion of arguments, extendable to 45 days for reasons to be recorded in writing.
“Keeping a criminal (or for that matter, even civil) matter undecided over unreasonable period after conclusion of arguments, be it the final arguments or even miscellaneous arguments erodes confidence of public in the justice delivery system,” the Court observed.
Accordingly, the Court allowed the plea and directed the trial court to pass orders on Kapoor's application within 15 days.
It further directed that a copy of its judgment be circulated to all Principal District and Sessions Judges in Delhi for being conveyed to courts dealing with criminal cases.
“Copy of this judgment be also sent to all Principal District & Sessions Judges, for being conveyed to all Courts in Delhi dealing with criminal cases to ensure that in a criminal matter once arguments on any issue, be it final arguments or miscellaneous arguments, and be it before the Court of Sessions or the Magistrate, are concluded, the order/judgment shall be pronounced within a reasonable time; and that the said reasonable time in case of final judgment shall be a period of at the most 30 days to 45 days as contemplated vide Section 258(1) BNSS and not more than 15 days in other cases, so that faith of public in criminal justice machinery does not get eroded,” the Court ordered.