Delhi High Court Closes Journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta's Appeal Against Indiabulls Injunction, Directs Expeditious Hearing In Trial Court
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday disposed of an appeal filed by journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta challenging an ex-parte injunction restraining him from publishing further content concerning Indiabulls and its promoter Sameer Gehlaut, while directing the trial court to expeditiously decide the pending interim injunction application.
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri passed the order after noting that the application was listed before the trial court on November 21. The High Court directed that, subject to the appearance of all defendants, the trial court shall ensure expeditious disposal of the application.
The appeal challenged an October 24 order of a Delhi court which, besides restraining further publications concerning Indiabulls and Gehlaut, directed the removal of a seven-year-old article co-authored by Guha Thakurta from public and archival access.
Noting that all the defendants, including the journalist, were informed about the next date of hearing, the Court said: “Subject to the appearance of all the defendants, the trial court shall ensure expeditious disposal of the application.”
In his appeal, Guha Thakurta had challenged the order passed by the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Patiala House Courts, in a defamation suit instituted by Indiabulls Nests Limited and Gehlaut against 41 defendants.
The journalist had contended that the impugned order was passed without notice to him and imposes an unconstitutional prior restraint on journalistic expression by prohibiting him from publishing “any further contents in relation to the plaintiffs” until the disposal of the suit.
The appeal challenged the injunction insofar as it concerns an article titled “The Maze of Political Links of Indiabull's Sameer Gehlaut”, co-authored by Guha Thakurta and Sourodipto Sanyal and first published on NewsClick on September 30, 2019. The article was subsequently reproduced on Guha Thakurta's website, paranjoy.in.
According to the appeal, the article examined, on the basis of public records, the political connections of Gehlaut, who was then the founder, promoter and chairman of Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited. It also carried Gehlaut's denial and the denials of the Indiabulls group.
The journalist argued that the article had remained online for nearly seven years before the plaintiffs initiated legal proceedings and that the injunction was granted without any finding that the publication was malicious or palpably false.
A principal ground raised in the appeal was that the district court failed to record reasons for granting an injunction without notice, as mandated under Order XXXIX Rule 3 of CPC.
The appeal stated that the plaintiffs had his email address and served the suit papers on him within a day of the injunction order. In these circumstances, there was no justification for proceeding against him without notice.
According to the appeal, the plaintiffs had sought an ex-parte injunction only until the next date of hearing and had undertaken to press for disposal of their application within 30 days.
However, it said that the trial court disposed of the injunction application finally and directed that the restraint would operate until the disposal of the suit.
Guha Thakurta argued that the blanket restraint on future reporting concerning the plaintiffs would prevent him from reporting on matters involving the CBI inquiry directed by the Supreme Court.