Delhi High Court Closes Plea Against Sunny Deol's 'Suryaa' After Makers Agree To Carry 'Work Of Fiction' Disclaimer
The Delhi High Court has closed a petition filed by a group of practising doctors challenging the trailer of Sunny Deol-starrer film 'Suryaa' over allegations that it portrays the medical profession in a defamatory manner, after the producer agreed to add a disclaimer clarifying that the film is a work of fiction.
Justice Amit Mahajan disposed of the petition filed by Dr. Nishant Soni and various other doctors after recording the undertaking given on behalf of the film's producer that an appropriate disclaimer would be included in both the film's trailer and the film itself.
The film “Suryaa: Ant Se Aarambh Tak” is set to hit theatres on November 20.
The doctors had approached the Court apprehending that the film's trailer projected doctors in a defamatory manner.
They contended that such an incorrect portrayal of doctors had also contributed to incidents of violence against frontline healthcare workers in certain parts of the country.
The doctors further submitted that doctors routinely face attacks from disgruntled family members of patients and that films portraying the medical fraternity in a negative light could further create an atmosphere detrimental to the safety of healthcare workers.
They also expressed grievance that their representations to the concerned authorities had not been addressed.
Appearing for the producer, Senior Advocate Rajiv Nayar submitted that the film was a remake of the original Malayalam movie 'Joseph', which had neither been banned by the authorities nor faced any such restrictions. He also pointed out that the original film had won several national and international awards.
Nayar further informed the Court that the producer was willing to place an adequate disclaimer in the trailer as well as the film, clarifying that it was a work of fiction and an adaptation of 'Joseph'.
Taking note of the submission, the Court observed that since the original Malayalam film had already been released and had not been banned by any authority, and the producer had undertaken to include the disclaimer, no further orders were required to be passed in the petition.
The Court also recorded the submission made by the Union of India that no permission had been granted to the film at that stage.
“Be that as it may, the present petition is disposed of only considering the apprehension raised by the petitioners and the undertaking as noted on behalf of Respondent No. 4 that an appropriate disclaimer will be put in the Trailer as well as in Film that the movie is a work of fiction and is only an adoption of the original Malayalam movie, namely, Joseph,” the Court said.
For context, a division bench had earlier refused to entertain a PIL filed by Dr. Nachiketa Bhatia and Dr. Dhruv Chauhan against the film. They had challenged the movie release on the grounds that its official trailer depicts physical violence against medical personnel as heroic and unfairly generalizes corruption in the healthcare profession.
In another development, the Rajasthan High Court yesterday issued notice on a plea against the movie while clarifying that the exhibition of the movie at any social media platform or appropriate forum shall be only after issuance of certificate under Section 5(B) of the Act of 1952.