Delhi High Court Denies Bail To Former Anti-Narcotics Cell Chief In Extortion Case After ₹48.87 Lakh Cash Recovery
The Delhi High Court has denied bail to a former head of the Delhi Police's Anti-Narcotics Cell, Dwarka, who is accused of running an alleged extortion racket with the help of his subordinates by threatening to falsely implicate people in NDPS cases.
Justice Girish Kathpalia dismissed the bail application filed by Subhash Chand, observing that his dominant and powerful position as head of the Anti-Narcotics Cell, coupled with the alleged extortion carried out at his behest by a subordinate Head Constable, made it an unfit case for grant of bail at this stage.
The Court noted that a Head, who was a subordinate of Chand, was caught red-handed while accepting a bribe of Rs. 2 lakh from the complainant. The prosecution alleged that the bribe was demanded to prevent registration of an NDPS case against her.
According to the CBI, the complainant had alleged that five officials of the Anti-Narcotics Cell, Dwarka, visited her residence and began searching the premises without authority. They allegedly brought a bag containing ganja from their own vehicle, placed it inside her house and threatened to falsely implicate her in an NDPS case.
The complainant alleged that the Head Constable initially demanded Rs. 25 lakh to ensure that no case was registered against her. The demand was subsequently reduced to Rs. 15 lakh, with Rs. 5 lakh to be paid initially.
During verification of the complaint, a WhatsApp call was made to the Head Constable in the presence of the verifying officer and independent witnesses. The complainant informed him that she could arrange only Rs. 2 lakh, which he allegedly instructed her to deliver that evening.
The CBI subsequently laid a trap on April 21, at the Anti-Narcotics Cell office in Dwarka. The Head Constable was allegedly caught red-handed while demanding and accepting Rs. 2 lakh from the complainant. The recovered currency notes matched those used in the trap, while the hand-wash test of the Head Constable also returned positive for phenolphthalein.
During the trap proceedings, the head constable was heard saying, “abhi Subhash Sahab se baat hui hai”, while the complainant stated that she was afraid of Subhash.
During a subsequent search of the Anti-Narcotics Cell premises, unaccounted cash amounting to Rs. 48,87,600 was recovered from an area adjacent to and below the window of the restroom attached to Chand's official room. A currency-counting machine was also found in his official room.
Rejecting the accused's contention that the cash had been recovered from a public place, the Court observed that the material forming part of the chargesheet indicated that the place was accessible only to him.
The Court also took note of the fact that a disproportionate assets case had subsequently been registered against Chand following further investigation by the CBI.
It further noted that the agency had found an antecedent demand of Rs. 20 lakh allegedly made by him on March 18, in connection with the detention of the complainant's daughter under the NDPS Act.
The CBI had also alleged that Chand destroyed his Samsung mobile phone and attempted to mislead the investigating officer by claiming that he had thrown it into a drain.
The Court found no convincing explanation from Chand regarding the alleged destruction of the phone, observing that it was unbelievable that a senior police officer would hand over his mobile phone to the investigating officer without obtaining any receipt or memo.
Opposing the bail plea, the CBI argued that the investigation revealed Chand's involvement in the alleged extortion racket and that the charges were yet to be considered by the trial court.
On the other hand, Chand contended that he had been falsely implicated to discourage other officials of the Narcotics Cell, alleging that the complainant and her family members were involved in several NDPS and Excise Act cases. He also argued that criminal law does not recognise vicarious liability and that he could not be held responsible for the bribe allegedly demanded and accepted by Ajay Kumar.
Rejecting the bail plea, the Court observed:
“Considering the overall circumstances described above, especially the dominant and powerful position held by the accused/applicant as head of the Anti Narcotics Cell and the extortion allegedly committed at his behest by his subordinate Head Constable, I do not find it a fit case to grant bail to the accused/applicant at this stage.”
The Court clarified that its observations were confined to the consideration of the bail application and that the trial court would take an independent view on the basis of the material on record.
Accordingly, the bail plea was rejected.
Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. Bharat Chugh, Mr. Jai Allagh and Mr. Maanish Mohan Choudhary, Advocates.
Counsel for Respondent (CBI): Ms. Rajni Gupta, Special Public Prosecutor, along with Inspector Abhijeet Shekhawat, ACB.