Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court on Thursday issued notice on LiveLaw Media's petition seeking restoration of two Instagram reels reporting proceedings before the Supreme Court, which were restricted in India allegedly pursuant to undisclosed legal requests.

A division bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma while issuing notice to the Union Government and Meta was informed that identical matters were scheduled for hearing on February 09, 2027. 

The court noted the submission of Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma appearing for the Union of India, that LiveLaw's petition can be treated as a representation and the Union will be passing a speaking order after hearing them.

"In response, counsel for petitioner states that it will be a mere formality. We permit respondents to file their counter within four weeks. List on January 18, 2027," the court said in its order. 

Advocate Apar Gupta, appearing for LiveLaw, submitted that the portal's reports were taken down from social media platforms Instagram and Facebook. He said that takedowns have happened, with the latest one being on Wednesday (November 18) pertaining to an Instagram reel on an affidavit filed by Delhi Police before the Supreme Court. Herein, the police had submitted that the Supreme Court's  order directing protection of journalists covering the anti-Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) protests was not intended to cover "so-called reel makers and social media influencers".

He said that takedowns have taken place using the automated filter used by the social media platforms pursuant to advisories and rules issued by Union Government. He added that LiveLaw's Instagram reels which were taken down and Rule 4(4) of IT Rules 2021. 

As the court asked the respondents to file their response to the petition, Gupta said, "I am under risk of entire account being suspended. The takedown happened last night is of reporting of Supreme Court, Delhi Police affidavit. I am not pressing for interim relief today but a shorter date". 

The plea also challenges the constitutional validity of Rule 4(4) of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, insofar as it mandates social media intermediaries to deploy automated tools to identify and restrict content allegedly identical to previously blocked information.

The legal news portal has also challenged two advisories issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) on October 08 and 10, alleging that they have been used to restrict its reports of proceedings before the Supreme Court on Instagram without furnishing any blocking order, notice or reasons.

The petition, filed by LiveLaw and its Director Sindhu T.P., seeks to strike down the amended Rule 4(4) as being ultra vires the Information Technology Act, 2000, and violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution of India.

The respondents are the Union Government through the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology and the Ministry of Home Affairs, as well as Meta Platforms Inc.

According to the petition, three reports concerning Supreme Court proceedings were restricted in India on LiveLaw's verified Instagram account, which has over 10 lakh followers.

The first report, published on October 27, was titled “ECI's Reply To SC On SIR, Form 6 & Bengal Appeals: Here's What Happened”. It explained the Election Commission of India's affidavit in Rakesh Kumar Singh v. Union of India, concerning the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. The report was restricted within 15 minutes of publication but was restored between 9 PM and 10 PM the same day.

The second report, published on October 29, explained the challenges to the Special Intensive Revision pending before the Supreme Court. It was restricted within approximately 15 minutes of publication and continues to remain inaccessible in India.

The third report, published on October 30, concerned Supreme Court proceedings in Women's Declaration International India v. Union of India, relating to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026. It was restricted on the same day and also continues to remain inaccessible.

The plea states that no blocking order, reasoned intimation or notice explaining the restrictions was furnished to the publisher in the matter.

It further states that Meta recorded that the content had been reviewed against its policies and restricted in locations where it went against local law.

LiveLaw's plea states that the grievances to Meta's Grievance Officer did not receive a substantive response and that the legal notices sent to the Centre and Meta on October 30, seeking restoration of the reports and disclosure of the underlying legal requests, went unanswered.

The petition argues that the amended Rule 4(4), insofar as it mandates automated identification and blocking of allegedly identical information, is contrary to the safeguards recognised by the Supreme Court in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India.

LiveLaw contends that the provision effectively requires intermediaries to adjudicate the legality of content themselves, without the procedural safeguards governing blocking under Section 69A of the IT Act.

“…the impugned Rule, in the form in which it has been implemented, authorises a prior restraint upon publication. The First Reel and the Second Reel were rendered inaccessible within fifteen minutes of their publication, before any human being could have examined a “legal request”, let alone conducted the “legal and human rights assessment” which Respondent No. 3 claims to have made, and while the reports were yet to reach the greater part of their audience,” the plea states.

The petition further points out that the amended provision converted the earlier obligation of significant social media intermediaries to merely “endeavour” to deploy automated tools into a mandatory requirement to deploy appropriate technical measures to proactively identify information exactly identical in content to previously disabled information.

The petition challenges the advisories issued by MeitY on October 08 and 10, contending that they have no statutory basis and cannot independently authorise intermediaries to restrict access to information.

The petition clarifies that LiveLaw is not questioning the use of technology to detect and remove material depicting rape or child sexual abuse but its challenge is confined to the mandatory automated identification and restriction of information allegedly identical to previously blocked content, particularly in its application to reports of judicial proceedings and news and current affairs content.

The plea also seems directions to the Centre and Meta to disclose the legal requests, intimations and communications on the basis of which its three reels were restricted.

The petition further seeks restoration of the two Instagram reels that continue to remain inaccessible in India and a declaration that the automated blocking mechanism cannot be used to restrict news reports without an order of a competent court or a reasoned intimation in accordance with Rule 3(1)(d).


Tags: