Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court has quashed the East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC) decision to recover additional payments made to garbage collection contractors for working under filthy or unhygienic conditions, holding that the deductions were arbitrary and unjustified.

Justice Amit Bansal directed the civic body to refund the amounts wrongfully deducted from the contractors' bills, along with 8% annual interest.

The dispute concerned payments described as 'Foul Condition' charges, which entitled contractors to higher rates for engaging workers in the collection and transportation of municipal garbage and waste.

The Court observed that the civic body could not recover these payments merely on the basis of audit and vigilance objections, particularly when it had itself acknowledged that the work undertaken by the contractors involved foul conditions.

"Therefore, in the opinion of this Court, the action of the respondents in deduction/recovery of the amounts from the payments due to the petitioners is clearly unjust and arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India," it held.

The Court was hearing five petitions filed by contractors challenging the deductions and recoveries made by the East Delhi Municipal Corporation (EDMC).

In January 2011, the unified MCD had prescribed different rates for workers deployed under general and foul conditions, with the latter attracting 25% higher remuneration. For instance, the daily rate for a beldar was fixed at ₹238 for general work and ₹297 for work under foul conditions.

Following a tender issued in 2012, the contractors were engaged to deploy vehicles and workers for lifting and transporting municipal solid waste, including garbage and drain silt.

After MCD's trifurcation, the contracts came under EDMC, which continued paying the higher rates until February 2016. However, from March 2016, the Corporation began deducting 25% from the contractors' gross bills, treating the earlier payments as excess amounts.

The civic body defended its action by citing audit and vigilance objections. It also argued that the work orders did not expressly provide for higher payments for work under foul conditions.

Rejecting these submissions, the High Court noted that the Corporation had itself admitted that the tender involved garbage collection work under foul conditions and that the higher rate was applicable.

The Court further observed that the Corporation's own Executive Engineer had defended the additional payments in response to the audit objections, stating that there was no irregularity. It also noted that the other municipal Corporations created after the trifurcation had continued paying the higher rates to contractors performing similar work.

"Different units of MCD arising out of the trifurcation cannot follow differential payment norms in respect of the same tender," it thus observed.

The Court held that the omission of the 'Foul Condition' clause from EDMC's work orders was merely an inadvertent clerical mistake and could not justify recovering payments previously made.

It also took note of the fact that the contractors were not issued any show-cause notice before the deductions commenced.

As such, the Court allowed all five petitions and ordered refund.

For Petitioner: Mr. Rajesh Vashisht and Mr. Piyush Kumar, Advocates

For Respondents: Mr. Sanjay Vashishtha, Standing counsel for MCD with Mr. Siddhartha Goswami and Mr. Aditya Sachdeva, Advocates for MCD.

Tags: