The Delhi High Court has rejected a plea filed by a murder convict challenging the President's decision to commute his death sentence to life imprisonment without remission, holding that the President has the constitutional power to direct imprisonment for the remainder of a convict's natural life.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja held that courts cannot substitute their opinion for that of the President once all relevant materials and circumstances have been considered before exercising the constitutional power of clemency under Article 72 of the Constitution of India.

The Court observed that judicial review of such decisions is limited to examining the manner in which the constitutional power has been exercised and not the decision itself.

“Once we find that the Hon'ble President of India had all the relevant inputs and took into consideration all the relevant factors before passing the Impugned Order, this Court cannot substitute the opinion of the Hon'ble President of India only on the ground that it itself may have decided the Mercy Petition in a different manner,” the Bench observed.

The Court was hearing a petition filed by one Jitendra alias Jitu Nainsingh Gehlot, challenging the condition imposed by the President while commuting his death sentence to life imprisonment in September 2016. The condition required him to remain in prison for the remainder of his natural life without any further remission by any authority.

Gehlot was convicted for his involvement in the murder of seven persons, including five women and two children, during a robbery at a Pune residence in August 1994. One of the women was pregnant.

The trial court awarded him the death penalty in February 1998. The Bombay High Court confirmed the sentence in July 1999, and the Supreme Court of India upheld the conviction and death sentence in September 2000. His review petition was also dismissed.

Gehlot had submitted a mercy petition before the President in June 2001. However, it was decided only on September 18, 2016, when the President commuted his death sentence to life imprisonment, subject to the condition that he would remain in prison for the remainder of his natural life without remission.

Challenging the condition, Gehlot argued that the prohibition on further remission was unconstitutional and that the President's power under Article 72 could not override the statutory and constitutional powers of the appropriate government to grant remission.

He also contended that the unexplained delay of more than 15 years in deciding his mercy petition violated his fundamental rights under Article 21. He further relied on his alleged prolonged solitary confinement and claimed that relevant aspects of his background, conduct, rehabilitation and reformation had not been adequately considered.

The Court referred to the Supreme Court's judgment in Epuru Sudhakar v. Government of Andhra Pradesh, reiterating that the exercise of clemency powers is amenable to limited judicial review.

It noted that such decisions can be interfered with where they suffer from non-application of mind, mala fides, arbitrariness, reliance on extraneous or irrelevant considerations, or exclusion of relevant material.

The Bench also relied on the Constitution Bench judgment in Union of India v. V. Sriharan, which upheld the validity of a special category of sentence involving imprisonment for the remainder of the convict's natural life without remission.

The Court observed that the Constitution Bench had recognised the power to impose such a sentence in exceptional cases where an ordinary life sentence subject to remission would be grossly inadequate having regard to the gravity and nature of the crime.

The Court acknowledged that there was an inordinate delay of more than 15 years in deciding Gehlot's mercy plea.

It observed that the prolonged delay and the period during which Gehlot remained under the shadow of the death sentence could have constituted sufficient grounds for commuting the death sentence to life imprisonment.

However, the Bench noted that the President was conscious of the delay and had specifically sought the opinion of the then Attorney General of India regarding the applicability of the Supreme Court's judgment in Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India.

The Attorney General had opined that there was a huge unexplained delay at every stage and recommended commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment.

The Ministry of Home Affairs, on the other hand, had recommended rejection of the mercy petition.

The Court noted that the President had the benefit of both opinions and had considered the competing views before passing the impugned order.

It accordingly held that the power to commute the death sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of the convict's natural life without remission vested in the President.

Finding no ground for judicial interference, the Court dismissed the petition. 

Tags: