The Delhi High Court has held that foreign nationals accused of overstaying their visas in India cannot be treated differently from other accused persons while considering their bail applications, clarifying that they cannot be directed to remain in detention centres as a condition for being released on bail.

A division bench comprising Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Arun Bhardwaj observed that merely because an accused is a foreign national, his right to bail cannot be curtailed.

It added that while courts can impose reasonable conditions to ensure the accused's presence during trial, keeping a foreign national in a detention centre would frustrate the very purpose of granting bail.

“Merely because an accused/convict is a foreigner, his right to bail cannot be circumscribed,” the Court observed.

The Bench was answering a criminal reference made by a Metropolitan Magistrate at Saket Courts concerning the grant of bail to foreign nationals accused of overstaying their visas under the Foreigners Act, 1946.

The reference arose from a bail application filed by a Nigerian national who had entered India in 2016 on a tourist visa valid for three months but continued to stay in the country after its expiry. He was apprehended and prosecuted under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act.

The Magistrate had referred three questions to the High Court, including whether granting unconditional bail to a foreign national accused of overstaying would effectively legalise his continued stay in India without a valid visa, whether such cases should be treated differently from other criminal cases, and whether detention in a detention centre could be imposed as a bail condition.

The High Court noted that the legal framework had subsequently undergone changes with the enactment of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, which repealed the Foreigners Act, 1946.

It also took note of the Ministry of Home Affairs' Standard Operating Procedure dated December 10, 2025, dealing with visa applications of foreign nationals involved in criminal cases who have been granted bail and whose presence is required in India for court proceedings.

The Court observed that foreign nationals are entitled to protection under Article 21 of the Constitution of India which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty.

Referring to the Supreme Court's judgment in Union of India v. Chidiebere Kingsley Nawchara & Ors., the Court reiterated that the State, as a sovereign authority, has the power to regulate, restrict and expel foreign nationals, however, their foreign citizenship cannot by itself be a ground to curtail their right to bail.

Answering the first question, the Court clarified that granting bail to a foreign national accused of visa overstay does not, by itself, legalise his continued stay in India or operate as a substitute for a valid visa.

It explained that the criminal court, while considering bail, examines the violation allegedly committed in the past and that restrictions on the foreign national's continued stay in India in the future would fall within the independent domain of the Central Government.

“The said power is wholly independent of the power to grant bail and can be exercised by the Central Government, notwithstanding the bail granted by a criminal Court,” the Court said.

The bench added that authorities have several options available to regulate the movement of foreign nationals, including directing them to reside at a particular place, restricting their movement to a specified area, regulating their conduct and associations, and requiring periodic reporting to designated authorities.

On the second question, the Court answered in the negative, holding that cases involving foreign nationals accused of visa overstay should not be treated differently from other criminal cases.

It said that such accused persons may be released from judicial custody on bail, subject to appropriate conditions, but cannot be directed to remain in a detention centre throughout the pendency of the trial.

Answering the third question, the Court held that bail may be granted subject to reasonable conditions concerning the accused's place of residence, restrictions on movement and periodic reporting, depending on the gravity of the offence and the likelihood of the accused evading trial.

However, it said that a condition requiring the foreign national to remain in a detention centre cannot be imposed by a criminal court while granting bail.

“Such a direction would frustrate the very order of bail and hence, cannot be imposed,” the Court held.

It clarified that the power to restrict or detain a foreign national under the applicable immigration framework rests with the competent executive authorities and is independent of the criminal court's power to grant bail.

Amicus Curiae: Advocate Harsh Prabhakar, assisted by Advocates Pallavi Garg, Yash Kotak, Dhruv Chaudhry, Shubham Sourav and Vijit Singh.

For the State: APP Aman Usman, assisted by Advocate Manvendra Yadav.

For the Union of India: CGSC Amit Tiwari, assisted by Advocates Ayushi Srivastava, Arpan Narwal, Kushagra Malik and Ujjwal Tyagi.

Tags: