Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court has strongly condemned the harassment and deaths of married women over dowry demands, describing the practice as a "sad and pathetic reality" of Indian society and a "collective shame".

Justice Vimal Kumar Yadav observed that despite marriage being a union of two individuals and their families, women continue to face harassment and cruelty over dowry demands, sometimes resulting in their deaths or driving them to suicide.

"How detesting and abhorric it is to kill or drive someone to take her own life. It cannot be described in words but it is the sad and pathetic reality of this society and a collective shame," the Court observed.

The Court said that although the exchange of gifts between families at the time of marriage is prevalent in different societies, the harassment and killing of brides for dowry is an abhorrent phenomenon rampant in Indian society.

It further observed that a woman enters her matrimonial home with expectations of happiness and a fulfilling married life, but those dreams are often shattered when she is subjected to harassment and pressured to obtain material things from her parents.

The Court noted that when the bride's family is unable to fulfil such demands, the harassment may continue, sometimes resulting in her death, suicide or divorce. In other instances, women continue to endure cruel treatment while suppressing their emotions.

Emphasising the responsibility of husbands towards their wives, the Court observed that a woman leaves behind her parents, siblings and other relatives after marriage, and it is therefore reasonable for her to expect love, care, protection and respect from her husband.

"In this context, it is primarily the duty and responsibility of the husband to take care of his wife, who has left behind everything and everyone, with whom she had a very strong bond, familial and consanguine," the Court said.

The Court also acknowledged the difficulties in proving matrimonial cruelty, observing that harassment generally takes place within the four walls of the matrimonial home and rarely comes to light unless the woman informs her parents or the situation escalates.

However, it clarified that notwithstanding the statutory presumptions available in dowry death cases, the prosecution must establish its case beyond reasonable doubt.

The observations were made while deciding appeals arising from the conviction of a husband and his family members in connection with the death of a woman, who had set herself on fire at her matrimonial home in October 2001, within two years of her marriage.

Her parents alleged that she had been harassed over demands for a motorcycle, gas stove, water motor and ₹25,000.

The trial court had convicted the accused under Sections 498A (cruelty) and 304B (dowry death) of IPC.

Examining the evidence, the Court found that the prosecution had failed to establish cruelty or harassment linked to dowry demands soon before the woman's death, as required for a conviction under Section 304B of IPC.

However, the Court found that the husband had subjected his wife to cruelty. It noted that she had earlier returned to her parental home because of matrimonial discord and was sent back only after her husband assured her family that he would treat her well.

The Court held that the persistent matrimonial discord and breach of that assurance constituted cruelty under Section 498A of IPC and that the husband's conduct had contributed to the circumstances leading to her suicide.

Accordingly, the Court converted the husband's conviction for dowry death under Section 304B of IPC into one for abetment of suicide under Section 306 of IPC, while maintaining his conviction under Section 498A of IPC.

It however acquitted his father and brother of all charges, finding that the allegations against them were vague and general.

Ms. Aishwarya Rao and Ms. Mansi Rao, Advocates with Appellants-inperson.

Mr. Mukesh Kumar, APP for State with SI Suneel Kumar Sahu, PS South Rohini.

Tags: