Click the Play button to listen to article

The Gauhati High Court has dismissed an insurance company's appeals challenging liability for compensation arising from an accident in which two Forest Department officers died while attempting to stop a truck, holding that its plea of contributory negligence was unsupported by evidence.

Justice Arun Dev Choudhury, observed, "The plea of 50% contributory negligence in particular remains a bare assertion in the written statement."

The observation came while hearing two appeals preferred by Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. challenging a common judgment and award dated November 21, 2014, passed in two MAC Cases. Both cases arose from a motor vehicular accident in which the husbands of the respective claimants had died.

The accident occurred in 2010, when Jahedul Islam, Forester-I, and Jyotish Das, Forester-II, were on duty at Budhipara/Agiya Beat Office. They noticed a truck loaded with sand coming from the Bolbola side and, suspecting that it was carrying forest produce, signalled the vehicle to stop.

The driver did not stop the vehicle, and when the two officers attempted to pursue and stop the truck, it knocked them down. Both sustained injuries and died. An FIR was lodged by the Range Forest Officer, Goalpara Range, under section 304/427 IPC, and upon investigation, a charge-sheet was submitted against the driver of the offending vehicle for rash and negligent driving, though subsequently, the driver was acquitted for want of evidence.

The Insurance Company challenged the finding of negligence and liability, contending that the deceased themselves were negligent, had violated traffic rules and that the accident occurred due to their own negligence.

The High Court noted that the Insurance Company had led no evidence and that the allegations made in its written statement were not supported by any evidence.

The Court observed, "There is no evidence on record establishing that the deceased had violated any particular traffic rule, that they had acted negligently in a manner which contributed to the occurrence, or that their negligence was either the sole cause or a contributing cause of the accident."

The Court further noted that the claimants had not witnessed the actual impact. It also considered the testimony of Binoy Kr. Nath, who claimed to have witnessed the occurrence but admitted during cross-examination that he was at a distance when he saw the Forest Officer signalling the vehicle. The Tribunal had therefore not placed implicit reliance upon his evidence.

The Court observed, "Though such evidence may not conclusively establish the manner of impact, it also does not establish the affirmative defense of contributory negligence pleaded by the Insurance Company."

The Court further held that the burden of establishing contributory negligence lies upon the party asserting it.

It observed, "The burden to establish specific plea of contributory negligence lies upon the party asserting it. A plea in the written statement is not evidence."

The Court also held that the driver's acquittal in the criminal proceedings could not, without evidence proved before the Tribunal, be a sufficient ground to apportion liability.

It observed, "A reference to the police case, violation of traffic rules, or the observation made in the criminal case against the driver, or his acquittal, cannot, without evidence proved before the Tribunal, be a sufficient ground to apportion liability or conclude that the deceased contributed to the accident."

The High Court accordingly found that the materials on record did not justify interference with the Tribunal's finding of fastening liability upon the offending vehicle and consequently upon the Insurance Company.

Dismissing both appeals, the Court directed the Insurance Company to deposit the compensation, after adjusting the amount already deposited or paid, together with interest, before the Tribunal in terms of the impugned judgment.

The Court further directed that the Tribunal's directions regarding disbursement and protection of compensation shall remain operative, subject to the minors attaining majority in the meantime or the death of any claimant.

Click Here To Read the Judgement

Tags: