Trial Court Can't Abruptly Close Accused's Right To Cross-Examine Witness Without Reasonable Opportunity: Gujarat High Court
The Gujarat High Court has held that trial court cannot close the right of a party to cross examine a witness without granting sufficient opportunity. In doing so the court granted an opportunity to the petitioner to further cross examine a witness for 45 minutes, which had been earlier closed by the trial court. The petitioner submitted that the trial court had in a suo-motu action closed...
The Gujarat High Court has held that trial court cannot close the right of a party to cross examine a witness without granting sufficient opportunity.
In doing so the court granted an opportunity to the petitioner to further cross examine a witness for 45 minutes, which had been earlier closed by the trial court.
The petitioner submitted that the trial court had in a suo-motu action closed his right to cross examine the doctor who conducted the post mortem. He submitted that despite the fact that the petitioner's counsel was asking the relevant question from the witness and conducting the relevant cross-examination, the Trial Court in the midst of the cross-examination, closed the right.
He submitted that the petitioner was not provided the true opportunity to cross-examine the witness to prove his defence, and prayed that he may be permitted to conduct further cross-examination of the doctor.
Justice Mool Chand Tyagi noted that the deposition of the witness as partly recorded and when the counsel for the petitioner was conducting the cross-examination, the Trial Court closed the right of the petitioner to cross-examine the witness on the ground that sufficient time had already been granted to the petitioner.
The further noted that neither the learned counsel for the petitioner sought time nor sought any adjournment while conducting the cross-examination when the right of the petitioner to further cross-examine the material witness came to be closed.
"The learned Trial Court ought to have struck a balance between the prosecution as well as the defence and ought to have given proper opportunity to both the parties to lead their respective evidence. In the facts of the present case, the learned Trial Court ought to have afforded a reasonable opportunity to learned counsel for the petitioner to complete the cross-examination of the witness," the court said.
The court said that the ends of justice would meet, if one opportunity is granted to the petitioner at his cost to conduct the remaining cross-examination the witness.
Allowing the petition the court directed that the doctor shall be called for further cross-examination at the cost of the petitioner.
The petitioner shall deposit the cost of Rs.2,000 with the Trial Court in advance, before the date fixed for further cross-examination and he shall complete the cross-examination within 45 minutes.
"It is also made clear that if the doctor remains present before the learned Trial Court on the date fixed for further cross-examination, no adjournment shall be granted to the learned counsel for the petitioner in any of the eventuality," the court added.