Click the Play button to listen to article

The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has granted bail to a man accused of facilitating a proposed terror attack on pilgrims in Katra, observing that he had remained in jail for more than six years and was already in custody when the offences were allegedly committed.

A Division Bench of Justice Sanjeev Kumar and Justice M.A. Chowdhary allowed the appeal filed by Mohd Khalid, who was accused of conspiring with Hizbul Mujahideen militants and facilitating their movement to Katra to carry out a fidayeen attack. The Court found that the mobile phone allegedly used to communicate with the militants was neither registered in his name nor shown to have been used by him, while the appellant was in custody at the relevant time.

“The appellant on the day of the alleged commission of the offences was in detention in a jail,” the Bench observed, adding that the SIM card allegedly used for communication with the militants could not, by itself, constitute substantive proof of his active involvement, particularly when he was incarcerated.

The Court further held that the appellant's background as a Pakistan-trained militant who had subsequently surrendered under the Government's rehabilitation policy could not, by itself, be a ground to deny him bail.

Background

The case arose out of FIR registered at Police Station Katra on October 18, 2019, under Sections 121-A and 121 of the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC) and Sections 15, 17, 18, 18-A and 39 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA).

According to the prosecution, information was received on April 24, 2019, regarding the movement of suspected terrorists in Katra town, allegedly posing a threat to public safety and the sovereignty and integrity of the country.

During the investigation, one Mushtaq Ahmad was arrested, who allegedly disclosed that he had purchased a SIM card from Kulgam and handed it over to co-accused Imitiaz Ali. The latter allegedly revealed that the SIM card had been procured on the directions of Mohd Khalid alias Junaid, a surrendered militant, for facilitating communication with terrorists and assisting them in carrying out an attack on pilgrims visiting Katra.

The prosecution alleged that Khalid had come into contact with Hizbul Mujahideen militants Tariq Ahmed Sheikh alias Tariq Moulvi and Abid Maagray alias Sajju Maagray through a district commander of the outfit. He allegedly acted as their overground worker and facilitated their travel to Katra and their return to Shopian in view of intensified security operations.

The investigating agency further relied upon call detail records and electronic communications to allege that Khalid was in contact with the militants and had assisted in planning a fidayeen attack in Katra town.

The prosecution also alleged that Khalid had travelled to Muzaffarabad in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir in 2004 for arms training and ammunition, and had subsequently remained active in areas of Rajouri, Reasi and Gool before surrendering before the police.

He was ultimately charged under Sections 121/121-A RPC and Sections 18 and 39 of the UAPA.

Khalid challenged the rejection of his bail application by the Special Court under TADA/POTA/UAPA Cases, Jammu. Before the High Court, his counsel argued that there was no substantive evidence connecting him with the alleged conspiracy. It was contended that the appellant was in jail in connection with another case during the period when the alleged offences were committed.

The defence also pointed out that the mobile phone and SIM card allegedly used for communicating with the militants were neither in Khalid's name nor shown to have been used by him. The SIM card had allegedly been obtained by co-accused Imitiaz Ali from Mushtaq Ahmad, while Khalid's wife, in whose name another phone was allegedly procured, had neither been arrayed as an accused nor cited as a prosecution witness.

Opposing the appeal, Senior Additional Advocate General Monika Kohli submitted that the appellant had actively participated in planning a proposed suicide attack in Katra, a prominent pilgrimage destination visited by devotees from across the country. She argued that the material collected during investigation, including call records and electronic communications, established his links with active Hizbul Mujahideen militants.

The prosecution also opposed bail on the ground that the stringent restrictions under Section 43-D(5) of the UAPA applied and that the appellant could abscond across the border if released.

Court's Observation

The Division Bench examined the material relied upon by the prosecution, particularly the allegation that Khalid had directed the procurement of a SIM card to facilitate communication between the militants involved in the proposed attack.

The Court noted that the appellant had remained in jail for more than six years and that his custody had also been transferred to the present case from another case.

It then recorded a crucial circumstance concerning his alleged involvement. It noted,

“The appellant is stated to have been in Jail for the last more than six years in this case, whose custody had also been transferred in this case from another case, which means that the appellant on the day of the alleged commission of the offences was in detention in a jail.”

The Bench further noted that the mobile phone allegedly used to communicate with the Hizbul Mujahideen militants was neither in the appellant's name nor under his use.

It observed,

“The SIM of a cell phone taken by co-accused Imitiaz Ali from another co-accused Mushtaq Ahmad cannot be a substantive proof about the active involvement of the appellant herein, particularly, when he was in custody.”

The Court thus found that the allegation concerning procurement of the SIM card, in the circumstances of the case, could not be treated as substantive proof of the appellant's active involvement, particularly when he was incarcerated during the relevant period.

The Bench also dealt with the prosecution's reliance on the appellant's past militant background. It noted that he had been a Pakistan-trained militant who subsequently surrendered before the police under the Government's rehabilitation policy.

Rejecting the proposition that this background could independently justify continued detention, the Court held,

“The appellant's background of being a Pak-trained militant, who later surrendered before the Police in a Rehabilitation Policy of the Govt., cannot be a ground to deny bail for his alleged role in the commission of aforestated offences in this case.”

The Bench clarified that it was refraining from making further observations on the merits of the prosecution case so as not to prejudice the ongoing trial. However, it recorded its satisfaction that the appellant was entitled to bail in the facts and circumstances of the case.

The Court also considered the nature of the offences under Sections 18 and 39 of the UAPA, the alleged role attributed to the appellant, the seriousness of the accusations and the prolonged period of incarceration.

In this regard, it observed,

“Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, alleged role of the appellant, his long incarceration of more than six years, nature of the offences punishable under sections 18 and 39 of UAP Act, gravity and seriousness of the offences, this Court is persuaded to grant bail in favour of the appellant.”

Allowing the appeal, the High Court set aside the order of the Special Court rejecting bail and directed the release of Mohd Khalid on bail, subject to terms and conditions to the satisfaction of the Trial Court.


Tags: