Click the Play button to listen to article

The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar has modified an order of the Jammu & Kashmir Special Tribunal to the extent that default on the part of the Municipal Authorities to decide the fate of an order, whereby building permission granted in favour of a private respondent was kept in abeyance, shall not lead to automatic cancellation of the said order.

The Court held that the order keeping the building permission in abeyance was a temporary measure, which could not remain in force in perpetuity, and that the Tribunal had rightly directed the Municipal Authorities to decide the issue within thirty days. However, the Court held that the petitioner was particularly aggrieved by the direction providing for deemed permission in favour of the private respondent upon default, and modified the order to that limited extent.

The Court was hearing a writ petition filed by the inhabitants of Syedabad Kupwara challenging an order dated 08.09.2025 passed by the J&K Special Tribunal, Srinagar, whereby a direction was issued to the official respondents to take a final call upon an earlier order dated 08.10.2022 within thirty days, failing which the said order was to be deemed to have been cancelled.

The petition was heard by Justice Sanjay Dhar, who observed,

“The petitioner is particularly aggrieved of the direction of the Tribunal which provides for deemed permission in favour of respondent No.6, if the respondent/Municipal Authorities fail to decide the matter within a period of 30 days. To this limited extent, impugned order dated 08.09.2025 deserves to be modified so as to take care of the concerns of the petitioner.”

Background

The dispute concerned a long history of litigation between the petitioners and respondent No. 6 with regard to proposed construction on land belonging to a Masjid situated at Kupwara. The Municipal authorities granted permission in favour of respondent No. 6 for construction of a commercial building vide an order.

The said order granting building permission was challenged by the petitioners by way of a revision petition before the J&K Special Tribunal, Srinagar, which came to be dismissed by the Tribunal vide an order dated 20.10.2022.

Thereafter, the Municipal authorities passed another order dated 08.10.2022, whereby the building permission granted in favour of respondent No. 6 was kept in abeyance.

The said order came to be challenged by respondent No. 6 by way of a revision petition before the J&K Special Tribunal, which came to be decided by the Tribunal in terms of the impugned order. The Tribunal directed the Municipal Authorities to take a decision in the matter within thirty days and, in default, provided that the said order would be deemed to have been cancelled and respondent No. 6 would be at liberty to proceed ahead with the construction as per the permission granted in its favour.

Court's Observation

The Court observed that it was not in dispute that the order dated 08.10.2022 issued by the Municipal Authorities keeping in abeyance the building permission in favour of respondent No. 6 was a temporary measure. The Court held,

“The said order cannot remain in force in perpetuity. The Municipal Authorities have issued the said order with a view to take a decision on the complaints/representations received by it from the petitioner and other persons objecting to the raising of construction on spot by respondent No.6.”

The Court further held,

“The validity of order dated 08.10.2022 can be stretched only up to the time the Municipal Authorities take a decision on the objections received relating to grant of building permission in favour of respondent No.6. Therefore, learned Tribunal has rightly directed the respondents/Municipal Authorities to decide the issue within a period of 30 days.”

However, the Court found merit in the petitioner's grievance regarding the direction of the Tribunal providing for deemed permission in favour of respondent No. 6 upon default. The Court accordingly modified the order to the extent that default on the part of the Municipal Authorities to decide the fate of the order dated 08.10.2022 shall not lead to automatic cancellation of the said order.

The Court, however, clarified,

“It is, however, made clear that the respondent/Municipal Authorities shall decide the issue within the time stipulated by the Tribunal which shall begin from today itself. It shall be open to the petitioner as well as respondent No.6 to make additional representations and produce documents before the official respondents, which shall be considered while taking the final decision in the matter.”

The writ petition, along with all connected applications, was accordingly disposed of.



Tags: