Public Servant Status Doesn't Shield Police Officer From Investigation If Material Linking Him To Cognizable Offence Emerges: J&K&L High Court
The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held that the status of a public servant does not shield a police officer from criminal investigation if a cognizable offence is disclosed and material linking him to the alleged offence emerges during investigation.Justice Shahzad Azeem made the observation while dismissing a petition filed by serving police officer Fayaz Ahmad Sheikh, who...
The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held that the status of a public servant does not shield a police officer from criminal investigation if a cognizable offence is disclosed and material linking him to the alleged offence emerges during investigation.
Justice Shahzad Azeem made the observation while dismissing a petition filed by serving police officer Fayaz Ahmad Sheikh, who sought quashing of an FIR registered against him at Police Station Achabal in connection with an alleged robbery and related offences under Sections 318(4), 309(4), 126(2) and 61(2)(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).
The Court observed that while the status of a public servant does not create any presumption of guilt, it equally does not confer immunity from investigation once material connecting the officer to a cognizable offence surfaces.
“The Petitioner is a serving police official who, according to the material collected during investigation, has been identified in connection with an alleged incident of robbery [Section 309 (4) BNS] and related offences. While the status of a public servant does not, by itself, create any presumption of guilt, it equally does not immune him from investigation once a cognizance offence is disclosed and material connecting him surfaces.”
It further held that an FIR is not an exhaustive account of the entire case and that investigating agencies are not barred from proceeding against persons whose involvement emerges during investigation, even if they were not initially named.
Background
The petitioner approached the High Court seeking quashing of FIR registered at Police Station Achabal for offences under Sections 318(4), 309(4), 126(2) and 61(2)(a) BNS.
He contended that the original complaint neither named him nor attributed any specific act of inducement, receipt of money, taking of gold, threat or prior agreement to him. According to the petitioner, the allegations against police personnel in the complaint were directed against “unknown persons”.
He further claimed that his name was introduced only after a Test Identification Parade (TIP) conducted on October 3, 2026.
The petitioner did not, at that stage, ask the Court to assess the TIP proceedings or treat his absence from the original complaint as conclusive grounds for quashing the FIR. Instead, he sought preservation of his posting, duty, deployment and movement records for October 3, 2025, along with the original TIP proceedings and related identification records dated October 3, 2026, so that his implication could be examined on legally sustainable material.
Court's Observation
Justice Azeem observed that an FIR is not an exhaustive account of the entire case and that the investigation may bring to light the involvement of persons who were not named at the outset.
The Court noted,
“It is well settled that an FIR is not an encyclopedia of the entire case and is always subject to the collection of requisite material during the course of investigation.”
It added that once a cognizable offence is reported, the police are under a statutory duty to register an FIR. There is equally no statutory bar on proceeding against persons whose complicity surfaces during investigation, even if they were not initially named.
Examining the circumstances in which the petitioner came to be arrayed as an accused, the Court noted that a Test Identification Parade had been conducted on October 3, 2026, in the presence of an Executive Magistrate after obtaining permission from the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Shangus.
An order dated October 16, 2026, recorded that the petitioner had been positively identified by Basharat Ahmad Kachroo. On the basis of that identification and a report submitted by the SDPO the petitioner was arrayed as an accused, and a notice under Section 35(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) was stated to have been served upon him.
The Court, however, noted that the original TIP proceedings, the earliest description furnished by the witnesses and the record of any prior opportunity of seeing the petitioner had not been placed before it.
The Bench also clarified that being a serving police official neither creates a presumption of guilt nor confers immunity from investigation. It remarked,
“…The Petitioner is a serving police official who, according to the material collected during investigation, has been identified in connection with an alleged incident of robbery [Section 309 (4) BNS] and related offences. While the status of a public servant does not, by itself, create any presumption of guilt, it equally does not immune him from investigation once a cognizance offence is disclosed and material connecting him surfaces”
It further observed that the petitioner had been identified during investigation in connection with an alleged robbery and related offences. The question at the present stage, the Court said, was limited to whether the FIR, read with the subsequent identification and the report leading to his implication, disclosed a cognizable offence against him.
The Court further also that the petitioner had not demonstrated that the material relied upon by the investigating agency was non-existent or that the investigation was being conducted with bias.
In these circumstances, it held,
“Interference under Section 528 of the BNSS read with Article 226 of the Constitution of India at the threshold would amount to stifling a legitimate investigation.”
Finding no merit in the petition, the High Court dismissed it in limine, along with the connected application.