NDPS Act's Stringent Bar Cannot Override Article 21: J&K&L High Court Grants Bail After 5 Years In 3-Kg Charas Case
The stringent restrictions on grant of bail under Section 37 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act cannot be allowed to result in indefinite incarceration of an undertrial, the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held while granting bail to a man accused of possessing three kilograms of charas, who had remained in custody for nearly five years without conclusion of his trial.
The Court observed that although the statutory bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act was attracted, the petitioner's prolonged incarceration and the likelihood of the trial taking further time justified his release on bail. It reiterated that the right to a speedy trial, guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution, cannot be rendered meaningless by the rigours of a special statute.
The Court was hearing a successive bail application filed by one Idrees Ahmed Khan, who was facing trial under Sections 8/20, 29 and 60 of the NDPS Act in connection with Crime No registered by the Narcotics Control Bureau, Jammu.
A Single Bench of Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani noted that the petitioner had been in custody since January 16, 2022, and that the trial was likely to take further time. The Court held,
“The petitioner/accused, on the ground of his long incarceration of five years in the case, deserves to be granted bail subject to some reasonable terms and conditions.”
Background
According to the prosecution, the NCB received information on January 16, 2022, that two persons, including the petitioner, were transporting a substantial quantity of narcotic substance in a Tata Sumo from Srinagar towards Jammu and were likely to reach Ban Toll Plaza, Nagrota.
The NCB team intercepted the vehicle and, during its search, allegedly recovered four packets wrapped in newspaper from a cavity in the rear door. The packets were found to contain charas weighing three kilograms, excluding the packing material.
The prosecution further alleged that the petitioner, in a statement recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act, disclosed that the consignment had been handed over to him by one Nazir Khan for delivery to co-accused Sirajbhai Gafurbhai Vahora in Jammu.
Following investigation, the NCB filed a complaint against the petitioner and two other accused. On March 11, 2023, the Trial Court framed charges under Sections 8/20, 29 and 60 of the NDPS Act against the petitioner and Sirajbhai. The third accused, Mohd Asif Wani, was discharged.
The petitioner had earlier approached the Trial Court seeking bail on the ground of prolonged incarceration. The application was rejected on June 6, 2025, primarily on the ground that the restrictions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act were attracted.
In his successive bail application before the High Court, the petitioner contended that his continued detention, despite the slow progress of the trial, violated his fundamental right to speedy trial under Article 21. He pointed out that the prosecution had listed only six witnesses and that, by September 25, 2025, only three of them had been examined, despite the Trial Court having directed the prosecution to lead evidence in May 2023.
Opposing bail, the NCB submitted that the petitioner was facing charges involving commercial quantity of charas and that the statutory conditions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act barred his release. It also argued that the evidence recorded during trial supported the prosecution case and that the petitioner could abscond or misuse the concession of bail if released.
Court's Observation
Taking note of the progress of the proceedings, the High Court recorded that, according to information received from the Trial Court, all six prosecution witnesses had subsequently been examined and the matter had been fixed for arguments on November 20, 2026.
The Court, however, found that the trial had suffered undue delay. It noted that the prosecution evidence had been called by the Trial Court on May 2, 2023, but by the time the successive bail application was filed on September 25, 2025, only three out of the six witnesses had been examined.
The Bench observed that the petitioner had remained in custody since January 16, 2022, and had completed approximately five years of incarceration. It also took note of the fact that, notwithstanding the examination of all six witnesses, the trial was likely to take further time.
Significantly, the Court acknowledged that the statutory bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act was attracted in the case, but held that the period already spent in custody could not be overlooked.
“Admittedly, in view of the offences charged against the petitioner/accused, the bar in terms of Section 37 of the NDPS Act is attracted in the case. The trial for its conclusion is likely to take some more time,” the Court observed, before concluding that the petitioner deserved bail on account of his prolonged incarceration.
The Bench then examined the constitutional principles governing the right to speedy trial and referred to the Supreme Court's decision in Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar, which had described unnecessary prolonged detention of undertrial prisoners as an affront to the norms of human liberty.
The High Court also relied upon Supreme Court Legal Aid Committee v. Union of India, where the Supreme Court had recognised that prolonged deprivation of personal liberty pending trial could violate Article 21 and that release on bail may become necessary where the trial is delayed beyond a reasonable period.
Reference was further made to Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb, in which the Supreme Court had held that statutory restrictions on bail do not oust the constitutional courts' power to grant relief where prolonged incarceration threatens fundamental rights.
The Court also relied upon Ashim alias Asim Kumar Haranth Bhattacharya v. National Investigation Agency, reiterating the principle that undertrials cannot be detained indefinitely and that courts must consider the period of incarceration alongside the likely time required for conclusion of the trial.
Another significant decision considered was Tapas Kumar Palit v. State of Chhattisgarh. The High Court reproduced the Supreme Court's observation in that case,
“However, many times we have made ourselves very clear that howsoever serious a crime maybe the accused has a fundamental right of speedy trial as enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution.”
Applying these principles, the High Court held that the petitioner's continued detention, despite having spent nearly five years in custody and with the trial likely to take further time, warranted the grant of bail.
The Court concluded that “it may meet the ends of justice in case the petitioner-accused is admitted to bail in the case, subject to some reasonable terms and conditions.”
Allowing the successive bail application, the High Court directed that Khan be released on bail in Crime No registered by the NCB, Jammu, upon furnishing personal and surety bonds of ₹2 lakh each, subject to the satisfaction of the Trial Court and the concerned Jail Superintendent. The surety bond was to be furnished by two persons from his near relatives, each liable for ₹1 lakh.