'Seeking Restitution Of Conjugal Rights While Making Baseless Allegations About Wife Raises Doubts About Bona Fides': Jharkhand High Court
The Jharkhand HC has held that a husband seeking restitution of conjugal rights while simultaneously making unsubstantiated allegations against his wife's character and chastity raises serious doubts about the bona fides of his claim and his professed intention to restore matrimonial harmony. The Court upheld the dismissal of a husband's petition seeking restitution of conjugal rights, observing that he had failed to establish that his wife had withdrawn from his society without reasonable cause.
A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Akhil Kumar held that a spouse seeking restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, must establish through clear and convincing evidence that the other spouse has withdrawn from the matrimonial relationship without reasonable excuse.
According to the husband, his wife was unwilling to live in a joint family, following which he arranged separate rented accommodation at Adityapur. He alleged that she remained dissatisfied with the arrangement and wanted to reside near her parents at Bagbera.
The husband, who was employed with Tata Steel Ltd., claimed that he subsequently obtained a company quarter in Kadma, where the couple lived for some time before his wife returned to her parental home. He further alleged that his wife and her parents pressured him to reside with them as a ghar jamai and threatened to implicate him in false criminal cases if he refused.
The husband stated that despite repeated requests and attempts at reconciliation, including proceedings before Nyaya Sadan, his wife refused to return to the matrimonial home. He consequently instituted proceedings under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act seeking restitution of conjugal rights. The wife denied the allegations against her and maintained that she had herself been subjected to cruelty by the husband.
On January 24, 2025, the Additional Principal Judge, Additional Family Court No. 2, Jamshedpur, dismissed the husband's suit. Aggrieved, he approached the High Court. Examining the evidence, the High Court found that the husband's allegation that his wife and her parents had insisted on his residing as a ghar jamai had been categorically denied by the wife and her witnesses. The husband had also failed to produce convincing evidence substantiating that allegation.
The Bench further observed that the husband's pleadings were largely filled with grievances and accusations against his wife, rather than demonstrating a genuine intention to resume matrimonial cohabitation.
Significantly, the Court noted that the husband had also accused his wife of maintaining an illicit relationship with one Sk. Siddique. However, he failed to substantiate the allegation through cogent or reliable evidence during cross-examination. Questioning the bona fides of the husband's restitution plea, the Court observed:
“This Court finds it rather incongruous that while the petitioner professes his desire to resume cohabitation and seeks restitution of conjugal rights, he simultaneously indulges in making unsubstantiated allegations affecting the chastity and character of his wife. Such conduct casts a serious doubt upon the bona fides of his claim and his professed intention to restore matrimonial harmony.”
The Bench explained that the object of restitution of conjugal rights is to restore cohabitation between estranged spouses and preserve the matrimonial relationship. It further held that the foundation of a restitution petition lies in the reciprocal entitlement of spouses to each other's society, consortium and companionship.
The Court emphasised that the burden rests upon the spouse seeking restitution to establish that the other spouse has withdrawn from the matrimonial relationship without reasonable cause. Whether the withdrawal is justified must be assessed by examining whether the surrounding circumstances make cohabitation impossible or unreasonable.
Applying these principles, the Bench found that the husband had failed to establish that his wife was living separately without sufficient or reasonable cause. The Court consequently held that the essential requirements for granting restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act had not been satisfied.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the husband's appeal and upheld the Family Court's judgment dated January 24, 2025, refusing restitution of conjugal rights.
Appearance:
For the Appellant: Mrs. Seema Kumari Singh, Advocate
For the Respondent: Mr. Jitendra Nath Upadhyay, Advocate