Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Karnataka High Court has held that complaints alleging illegal detention and custodial torture must ordinarily be heard by a Division Bench of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission, unless the Chairperson specifically directs that they be placed before a Single Bench.Justice T.P. Vivekananda observed that any departure from the normal procedure prescribed for adjudicating...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Karnataka High Court has held that complaints alleging illegal detention and custodial torture must ordinarily be heard by a Division Bench of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission, unless the Chairperson specifically directs that they be placed before a Single Bench.

Justice T.P. Vivekananda observed that any departure from the normal procedure prescribed for adjudicating such complaints requires a special order from the Chairperson of the Commission.

The Court was considering a petition filed by police officer Laxman K. Pawar challenging the Commission's November 29, 2022 order recommending initiation of disciplinary proceedings against him under the Karnataka State Police (Disciplinary Proceedings) Rules, 1965. He had also challenged the Commission's subsequent order rejecting his review petition.

The disciplinary action was recommended following a complaint filed by Ashish Kohli, who alleged that he had been harassed and illegally detained at a police station.

Initially, an inquiry conducted by a Deputy Superintendent of Police found the allegations to be false. However, a subsequent inquiry conducted by another officer of the same rank found that Kohli had been taken to the police station and detained without any written complaint or FIR.

Based on the subsequent inquiry report, the Commission held that the allegations against the police officer, including the receipt of ₹40,000 from the complainant, had been established and recommended disciplinary proceedings against him.

Before the High Court, Pawar contended that the complaint involving allegations of illegal detention and custodial torture ought to have been heard by a Division Bench of the Commission rather than a Single Bench.

He relied on Regulation 11(4) of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 2007, which provides that complaints relating to custodial death, custodial torture, custodial rape and illegal detention shall normally be heard by a Division Bench. Other complaints are ordinarily assigned to a Single Bench, unless otherwise directed by the Chairperson.

Opposing the petition, counsel for the Commission submitted that the 2007 Regulations had been repealed by the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 2020. It was further argued that Regulation 11(4) was directory rather than mandatory and permitted such complaints to be considered by either a Single Bench or a Division Bench.

After considering the submissions, the High Court held that complaints alleging illegal detention and custodial torture were required to be adjudicated by a Division Bench unless the Chairperson specifically directed otherwise.

The Court observed, "The word normally depicted in regulation (4) of Regulation 11, will have to be understood as in usual course. If there has been an exception to the normal course, then special order at the hands of the Chairperson was necessary."

It further explained that although the expression "normally" allows for exceptions to the prescribed procedure, such departures cannot be arbitrary.

"Under the administrative law principles, the word 'shall' indicates mandatory intent and the word 'normally' qualified directory. In the provision in question both the aforesaid expressions are used. Therefore, any administrative or quasi judicial authority departs from the normal rule the exception cannot be arbitrary," the Court observed.

Accordingly, the High Court held that the Commission's orders were unsustainable on the ground of lack of jurisdiction and remanded the matter for fresh adjudication.

"This Court is of the view that the impugned orders at Annexures-A and B are unsustainable only on the ground of lack of jurisdiction and the matter requires re-consideration by the Hon'ble Division Bench of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission."

Appearance: Advocate GOWTHAMDEV C ULLAL for Petitioner.

Advocate RAJASHEKHAR K, FOR R1.

Advocate AMANDA CHAKRAVARTHI, FOR R2.

Tags: