Hindu Succession | Children Of Daughter Who Died Before 2005 Amendment Can't Claim Coparcenary Rights Through Her: Karnataka High Court
The Karnataka High Court has ruled that the descendants of a daughter who died before the commencement of the Hindu Succession Amendment Act, 2005, cannot claim a share in the ancestral property through her.
For context, the 2005 Amendment Act vests coparcenary rights in daughters by birth, placing them on an equal footing with sons.
Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Vineeta Sharma vs. Rakesh Sharma & others (2020), the High Court said it is settled that while the father need not be alive on September 9, 2005—the date on which the 2005 Amendment Act came into force—the daughter must have been living on that date for her children to claim coparcenary rights in the property.
“The Hon'ble Supreme Court, while holding that the father need not be alive on 09.09.2005, specifically stated that the daughter should be living on that day. The recognition of a right by birth cannot be read independently of the commencement or the statutory provision. The amended Section 6 did not operate during the lifetime of a daughter who died before 09.09.2005. Consequently, a coparcenary right arising solely under the amendment could not have vested in her before her death,” the Court said.
Justice Lalitha Kanneganti was hearing a petition filed by the parties arrayed as the fourth and fifth defendants in the partition suit instituted by the descendants of a daughter. In the suit, the plaintiffs also sought a declaration that subsequent sale deeds executed in respect of the said properties were not binding on them.
The petitioners filed an application before the Trial Court seeking the rejection of the plaint, which the Court dismissed. Aggrieved by this decision, they approached the High Court.
The High Court noted that the plaintiffs' mother had died on June 24, 2005, before the amended provision became operative.
“Her children and grandchildren cannot claim through her a right that she did not acquire during her lifetime. The mere fact that the plaintiffs are descendants of a daughter of the family does not, by itself, confer upon them a right to partition under the amended provision. Their entitlement must arise from a legally recognized interest, and the statutory right relied upon vested in their predecessor,” the Court observed.
The High Court held that the Trial Court had failed to take into account that the plaintiffs had no legal right to seek partition as their mother was not alive when the amendment came into force.
Accordingly, the High Court set aside the Trial Court's order and dismissed the partition plaint.