Person Claiming Indian Citizenship Can't Be Deported Without Fair Determination Of Nationality: Karnataka High Court
The Karnataka High Court has held that a person claiming Indian citizenship cannot be deported as a foreign national without following a fair and lawful procedure to determine their nationality, even if the authorities dispute the authenticity of the documents relied upon to establish citizenship.Justice CM Poonacha accordingly directed the authorities not to deport a man suspected of being...
The Karnataka High Court has held that a person claiming Indian citizenship cannot be deported as a foreign national without following a fair and lawful procedure to determine their nationality, even if the authorities dispute the authenticity of the documents relied upon to establish citizenship.
Justice CM Poonacha accordingly directed the authorities not to deport a man suspected of being a Bangladeshi national until necessary steps are undertaken to determine his nationality after giving him an adequate opportunity to establish his claim of Indian citizenship.
"Till the further steps as regards the nationality of the petitioner is undertaken by the concerned authorities the repatriation / deportation of the petitioner shall not be undertaken by the concerned authorities."
The Court clarified that although the burden of establishing Indian citizenship rests on the person making such a claim, the authorities are nevertheless required to follow a fair, lawful and reasoned procedure before deporting them.
The Court was hearing a petition filed by one Abdul Rahim, who challenged a movement restriction order passed by the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer (FRRO), Bengaluru, on March 5, 2026.
Rahim was apprehended by officials of the Parappana Agrahara Police Station during a drive to identify suspected illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. He was subsequently referred to Utile Foundation in Kothanur, Bengaluru, under an order directing him not to leave the facility until his repatriation.
Advocate Clifton D. Rozario, appearing for Rahim, submitted that the petitioner was born on April 14, 1979, in New Seemapuri, Delhi, and had moved to Bengaluru in 2014, where he was engaged in waste management and scrap trading activities.
It was argued that Rahim was an Indian citizen by birth and possessed several government-issued documents, including a birth certificate, passport, voter identity card, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving licence and an identity card issued by the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP).
The petitioner contended that the movement restriction order proceeded on the assumption that he was a foreign national without providing him an adequate opportunity to establish his Indian citizenship.
The Court was also informed that Rahim had been convicted by a Sessions Court in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, in June 2012, in a case under the Foreigners Act, 1946, on the allegation that he was a Bangladeshi national.
Rahim had challenged the conviction before the Allahabad High Court, which granted him bail in July 2012. His criminal appeal remains pending. The petitioner argued that his liberty, secured through a judicial order granting bail, could not be curtailed through an executive order.
It was further submitted that Rahim was the primary earning member of his family, comprising his wife and infant child, and that the movement restriction order had deprived him of the opportunity to earn his livelihood.
Opposing the petition, Additional Solicitor General Arvind Kamath appearing for the authorities submitted that Rahim was a Bangladeshi national who was claiming Indian citizenship on the strength of forged or fabricated documents.
The authorities disputed the authenticity of his birth certificate, which recorded that he was born in April 1979 at Guru Gobind Singh Government Hospital in Delhi. They pointed out that the hospital was established only in December 1995 and that no corresponding birth record was available. It was also submitted that the death certificate of Rahim's father could not be verified from the records of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi.
The authorities contended that the petitioner had relied upon fraudulent documents to obtain other identity documents and that his petition was liable to be dismissed.
The High Court examined the provisions of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025, governing restrictions on the movement and residence of foreign nationals. It reiterated that while the fundamental rights under Article 19 of the Constitution, including the rights to move freely and reside anywhere in India, are available only to Indian citizens, the protections under Articles 14 and 21 extend to all persons, including foreigners.
Examining the documents produced by Rahim, the Court noted that his voter identity card had been issued in December 2005 and that he also possessed a passport issued in June 2018. The Court observed that the issuance of a passport indicated that some process of verification had been undertaken by the authorities.
"The said documents clearly indicate that the petitioner has been residing in India for a considerably long period of time, throughout the period of which the petitioner has consistently asserted that he was an Indian citizen," the Court said.
Although the authorities disputed the birth certificate on the ground that the hospital mentioned in it did not exist at the time of the petitioner's alleged birth, the Court held that the objection could not be considered in isolation from the other documents relied upon by him.
"Since the petitioner is asserting that he is an Indian citizen by birth and is relying upon various documents in support of the same, the respondent - authorities ought to have afforded an opportunity to the petitioner and a fair process ought to have been undertaken to adjudicate the aspect regarding the assertion of citizenship by the petitioner by considering the various documents relied upon by him before any order is passed, whereunder the petitioner is sought to be removed from India."
The Court also noted that the movement restriction order did not refer to Rahim's earlier conviction or the criminal appeal pending before the Allahabad High Court. Instead, the order proceeded on the premise that he was a foreign national.
The Court further observed that the FRRO had examined the documents relied upon by Rahim only after issuing the movement restriction order and during the pendency of the writ petition. It held that the assessment undertaken by the FRRO was not an adjudication of nationality in accordance with the procedure contemplated under the applicable law.
The Court also noted that the question of whether a person is a foreigner is required to be determined through the procedure prescribed under the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025.
However, the High Court rejected the petitioner's contention that the authorities lacked the power to restrict his movement. It held that Section 7(2)(f)(ii) of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, empowered the authorities to require a person to reside at a particular place. Consequently, the direction requiring Rahim to remain at Utile Foundation could not be regarded as being without statutory authority.
The Court nevertheless distinguished the power to restrict movement from the power to deport a person whose nationality had not been lawfully determined. It observed that even though the burden was on Rahim to establish his Indian citizenship, the authorities were required to adopt a fair procedure before removing him from the country.
"A fair procedure is to be adopted before the petitioner is deported/removed from India," the Court said, adding that the requirement of a fair, lawful and reasoned process applies notwithstanding the burden on the petitioner to prove citizenship.
The Court further held that the authorities were required to give Rahim an opportunity to present and explain the documents supporting his citizenship claim before concluding that he was a Bangladeshi national; and that Rahim's repatriation could arise only after his nationality had been determined in accordance with law.
Appearance: Advocate CLIFTON D ROZARIO, for Advocate MS. MAITREYI KRISHNAN, for Petitioner.
ASG K ARAVIND KAMATH, A/W AGA SHIVA REDDY V, FOR R1 TO R4
CGC SWAMINI GANESH MOHANAMBAL for R5.