Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Kerala High Court recently clarified that courts cannot independently order police investigation against a petitioner in a defreezing plea merely because large amounts were credited into his bank account. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 626]The Division Bench of Justice Devan Ramachandran and Justice Basant Balaji was considering an appeal against a Single Judge's order directing the police to conduct...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Kerala High Court recently clarified that courts cannot independently order police investigation against a petitioner in a defreezing plea merely because large amounts were credited into his bank account. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 626]

The Division Bench of Justice Devan Ramachandran and Justice Basant Balaji was considering an appeal against a Single Judge's order directing the police to conduct an investigation against a person based on a prima facie finding that his account was a mule account.

“after the learned Single Judge found against the appellant on merits, he went on to order an investigation against him and his account, noticing that there were certain “large amounts also credited in the account of the petitioner”…the learned Judge could not have ordered an investigation against the appellant or his account, solely because of certain entries in the statement of such account presented by the SBI, in the course of the Writ Petition. None of the Police Officers on record imputes that the appellant is involved in any Crime; and, at best - at least as of now - the only insinuation appears to be that his account has entries of sums, which the creditors may have obtained as proceeds of Crime. This itself being only a presumption at this stage, an investigation cannot be ordered by this Court independently,” the Court observed.

The appellant/petitioner is a 20 year who was working as a billing staff in a restaurant. He approached the Single Bench after the bank froze his account after receiving six requisitions from the SHO of Cyber Crimes Cell, Puducherry. He explained that the disputed sums of Rs. 50,000 each were transferred to his account by his cousin and her husband, who are abroad, for constructing a house for them.

The Single Bench referred to the appellant/petitioner's Statement of Account and noted that other large amounts were also credited into his account and the same were not properly explained by him. It then dismissed the plea and went on to order the police to conduct an investigation against the appellant/petitioner after rendering a prima facie finding that he was using his account as a money mule. Aggrieved, he preferred an appeal before the Division Bench.

The appellant argued that he had explained the source of money to support his plea for unfreezing and if the Single Bench was not inclined to allow the same, he could have dismissed it without ordering an investigation. It was pointed out that there was no other pending against him and therefore, the Single Bench ought not to have passed such an order.

The bank conceded that it had not received any information on any other investigation against the appellant or his account. The government pleader also confirmed that the SHO of the Cyber Crime Cell had not issued any letter implicating the appellant or his account.

After hearing the parties, the Court set aside the direction for police probe. It also made it clear that the freezing of the account would only be to the extent of the six requisitions and not beyond.

Thus, it allowed the appeal.

Counsel for the appellants: Ipsita Ojal, Mariyamma A.K., Manas P. Hameed, Laya Simon

Counsel for the respondents: Nazeeba O.H. – Senior Government Pleader, Amal George – Standing Counsel - SBI

Click to Read/Download Single Bench Judgment

Tags: