story

The Kerala High Court recently held that unsuccessful treatment does not automatically establish that there is medical negligence on the part of doctors.[2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 628]Justice Mohammed Nias C.P. observed that merely because treatment was unsuccessful, it cannot be presumed that there was medical negligence, in the absence of cogent medical evidence:“In every case where treatment is...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Kerala High Court recently held that unsuccessful treatment does not automatically establish that there is medical negligence on the part of doctors.[2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 628]

Justice Mohammed Nias C.P. observed that merely because treatment was unsuccessful, it cannot be presumed that there was medical negligence, in the absence of cogent medical evidence:

“In every case where treatment is not successful, or the patient dies, it cannot be automatically assumed that the medical professional was negligent. To indicate negligence, there should be material available on record or appropriate medical evidence should be tendered. Without reference to evidence, mere assumption would not be sufficient to fasten liability for medical negligence.”

The Court added:

“As repeatedly held by the Apex Court in several decisions,…to hold a medical practitioner liable for negligence, a high threshold must be met. This is to ensure that these doctors are focused on deciding the best course of treatment as per their assessment rather than being concerned about possible persecution or harassment that they may be subjected to in high-risk medical situations. Therefore, to safeguard these medical practitioners and to enable them to discharge their medical duty freely, a higher burden of proof must be discharged by the plaintiff.”

The appellants before the Court were the plaintiffs in a suit claiming compensation alleging medical negligence on the part of respondents/defendants. The plaintiffs, who were husband and wife, initiated the suit alleging that due to the negligence on the part of the hospital and gynaecologist (defendants), their third child died during delivery. They claimed Rs. 1.5 lakhs as compensation.

The defendant hospital filed written statement admitting that the second plaintiff was admitted in the hospital during delivery but there was no negligence on its part and that the labour was attended with utmost care and caution. It was stated that there was regular monitoring of the mother and the foetus, and that a decision was made for a C-section to save the mother and the baby once the fetal heart sound came down from normal. However, the baby delivered had no heart beat and even though all possible resuscitative measures were tried, revival was not possible, it was stated. It was further pointed out that the suit was initiated after more than a year since the delivery at the instigation of other persons. The defendant gynaecologist also filed a written statement stating that the C-section was done after getting written consent and that the same was done with utmost care and caution.

The trial court found that the medicine to induce labour was administered in excess and that it was not sure whether the defendant gynaecologist was present at all times when the said medicine was administered. It also found that there was delay in deciding for C-section and other faults on the part of the hospital staff. It granted compensation of Rs. 1.5 lakhs with interest to the plaintiff, to be realized from the defendants.

Aggrieved, the defendants challenged the decision before the first appellate court. The first appellate court found that the evidence of the parties was not properly considered and set aside the decree. Challenging this, the plaintiffs approached the High Court and preferred a second appeal.

The appellants argued that the defendants' admission would clearly point to negligence on their part. Among the contentions raised were that there was no paediatrician in the labour room, some of the hospital records were maintained by the nurses instead of the doctor, etc. They also relied on various case laws.

The respondents/defendants argued that the trial court findings were not in accordance with the evidence adduced. It was also pointed out that the plaintiffs had not even pleaded the particulars of the negligence alleged against the doctor or the hospital. They added that there was an anesthetic inside the delivery room who was trained to resuscitate baby and there was no need for a paediatrician.

After hearing the parties, the Court opined that the plaintiffs have not shown through medical evidence what a reasonably competent obstetrician would have done differently in the same circumstances or that any different course would have saved the baby. 

“A finding of negligence that rests on assumptions, and runs contrary to the case sheet and to expert opinion not rebutted by any medical evidence, cannot be sustained, and the first appellate court was not only entitled but bound to set it aside. Its conclusion being one of fact, supported by the evidence and not shown to be perverse, no interference is warranted,” it added.

The Court thus dismissed the appeal.

Counsel for the appellants: V.C. Madhavankutty, Bijo Francis

Counsel for the respondents: Arun Mathew Vadakkan, George Cherian Karippaparambil, Rajesh Cherian Karippaparambil, Santheep Ankarath

Tags: