Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Kerala High Court has cautioned the media against reporting oral courtroom remarks and exchanges between judges and lawyers in a manner that could damage their professional reputations, observing that informal conversations and light-hearted jokes made during court proceedings should not be amplified out of context. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 629]Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan made the...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Kerala High Court has cautioned the media against reporting oral courtroom remarks and exchanges between judges and lawyers in a manner that could damage their professional reputations, observing that informal conversations and light-hearted jokes made during court proceedings should not be amplified out of context. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 629]

Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan made the observations while dismissing a writ petition filed by advocate T.B. Mini, who represented the survivor in the 2017 Actress Assault Case.

The petition sought initiation of criminal contempt proceedings against the then Ernakulam Principal District and Sessions Judge Honey M. Varghese over allegedly derogatory remarks made about the advocate in open court.

The Court emphasised that lawyers are entitled to dignity and fair treatment from the Bench, while also cautioning against treating every informal courtroom exchange as a matter warranting public controversy.

“The dialogues in the courtroom should be confined to the courtroom itself,” the Court observed, emphasising the need for mutual respect, professional solidarity and restraint between judges and lawyers.

According to the petitioner, the Judge allegedly remarked that she had attended the trial on fewer than ten days, spent only half an hour in court on the days she attended, and slept during that time, treating the courtroom as a place to rest.

The petitioner claimed that the remarks were false, humiliating and damaging to her professional reputation. She alleged that the comments were subsequently circulated through television channels, YouTube channels and social media platforms, triggering abusive and body-shaming remarks against her and questioning her professional competence.

She contended that the alleged remarks amounted to criminal contempt under Section 16 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and sought a direction to place the matter before the Chief Justice for consideration of suo motu contempt proceedings. She also sought the expunction of the alleged remarks and directions for the removal of media reports and online content concerning them.

The petitioner had earlier approached the Advocate General seeking sanction to initiate contempt proceedings. However, the Advocate General rejected the request, holding that even if the alleged remarks had been made, they would not amount to criminal contempt.

While delivering the judgment, the Court at the outset stated that Courtroom remarks by a presiding officer may be momentary, but their circulation may embarrass the person against whom they are made.

“Lawyers deserve dignity and fair treatment, and they should not leave the court, after arguing a case, feeling that the court insulted or humiliated them. A lawyer's right to argue a case on behalf of his/her client before a court of law includes the right to receive fair treatment from the Bench.” the Court said.

The Court noted that judges and lawyers may sometimes exchange jokes or make comments during proceedings without intending to cause harm. A courtroom where only legal interpretations and factual arguments are discussed can become monotonous for judges, lawyers and litigants alike, and occasional humour may help ease the atmosphere

“Therefore, it is improper for the media to cover such dialogues between a lawyer and a Judge in a way that tarnishes the image of a lawyer or a Judge. The media should know what to neglect and what to project based on their journalistic experience in a sensible manner” the Court said.

It also cautioned members of the Bar against being carried away by reactions on social media.

“Let us neither amplify a colleague's embarrassment nor rush to hold the Bench in contempt without having the full picture and the context in which any remarks are made by the Judge. ” the Court added.

It further said that the response of the bar and bench should be guided by professional solidarity, restraint and mutual respect, rather than by the impulse to share.

“I am sure that the media, who always protect the democratic principles of the country, know what to report and what not to report, and they will always uphold those journalistic principles in future too. I leave it there.” the Court remarked.

The Court then went on to examine the petition and found that there was insufficient material before it to establish that the alleged remarks had actually been made by the judicial officer.

The Court noted that the petitioner was not present in court when the alleged statement was made and had learnt about it through her junior colleague. However, no affidavit from the junior advocate was filed before the High Court to substantiate the allegation.

The Court also declined to rely on a photocopy of the junior's affidavit that had been annexed to the petition submitted before the Advocate General.

It further noted that the alleged remarks had not been recorded in any judicial proceedings and that the petitioner primarily relied on her own version, the alleged account of her junior and media reports.

The Court held that contempt proceedings against a judicial officer could not be initiated merely on the basis of hearsay allegations and media reports, without a proper factual foundation.

It accordingly declined to issue notice to the third respondent, Smt. Honey M Varghese, observing that judicial officers should not routinely be called upon to respond to writ petitions filed without supporting material.

The Court also agreed with the Advocate General's conclusion that the alleged remarks, even if assumed to be true, would not constitute criminal contempt.

Relying on the Kerala High Court's decision in Berely v. Xavier and Another [1986 KHC 278], the Court reiterated that excessive or extravagant language must be distinguished from contempt of court.

The judgment observed that even if the remarks had been made to a lawyer engaged in stressful professional duties, the same could not, in the circumstances, be treated as criminal contempt.

The Court went on to note the tendency to treat oral exchanges between judges and lawyers as newsworthy events and said,

“It is true that judicial officers should not make oral observations in Court, especially in this new era of social media...The media should also bear in mind that oral observations by judges and lawyers should not be treated as news, especially when it may hurt a party. The judges speak through their judgments. To decide a case or persuade a lawyer to argue it, there may be some courtroom dialogue. It is improper for the media to make this news, as it will cause serious damage to the lawyers and the Judges too.”

Describing judges and lawyers as officers of the court and two sides of the same coin, the Court stressed that neither is above the other.

The Court also reassured the petitioner that there was no complaint against her professional capacity as a lawyer and that she should not be troubled by social media comments.

“A lawyer is to be assessed by the judges, and this Court has no doubt about the petitioner's capacity as a lawyer. Therefore, the petitioner should also ignore those comments and carry out her professional duties to the best of her ability, and one day she will be rewarded for the same. I leave it there.” the Court added.

Ultimately, the Court found that there was no merit in the petition and hence dismissed the petition.

Counsel for Petitioner: K. Nandini

Counsel for Respondents: P.A. Mohammed Shah (Addl. AG), Harikumar G, M, Jayakrishnan (CGC)

Tags: