The Kerala High Court has directed the State Police Chief to ensure that the judicial directions governing the administration of Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church are not violated during the ongoing visit of Moran Mor Ignatius Aphrem III, Patriarch of Antioch, to Kerala.

Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan passed the order in a writ petition seeking directions to prevent the Patriarch from conducting religious activities, including Holy Qurbana, at St. Mary's Church (Cathedral), Manarcad, Kottayam, or any other church under the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, allegedly in violation of existing court decrees.

The Court directed the third respondent, the State Police Chief, to ensure that the directions contained in the judgments produced as Exhibits P1 and P2, as well as the Supreme Court's judgment in K.S. Varghese and Others v. St. Peter's and St. Paul's Syrian Orthodox Church and Others,[(2017) 15 SCC 333], are not violated during the Patriarch's visit.

The Court further clarified that the State Police Chief must ensure that the visa conditions issued to the Patriarch are not violated.

The petitioners, who are parishioners of St. Mary's Church, Manarcad, approached the High Court seeking to direct the official respondent to ensure that the Patriarch of Antioch does not indulge in religious activities including the performance of Holy Qurbana in St, Mary's Cathedral, Manarcaud or in any other churches of Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, during his visit to the State as a State Guest from 11 November to 16 November, 2026.

The petitioners relied on a news report published on 6 November  by a Malayalam media, which allegedly indicated that arrangements were being made for the Patriarch to enter St. Mary's Church, Manarcad, and celebrate Holy Qurbana on November 15.

The petitioners pointed out that the Government's programme for the Patriarch, issued through a government order dated November 5, 2026 issued by the General Administration (Protocol) Department of Kerala mentioned Holy Qurbana at 8.30 AM on November 15 without specifying the venue.

They contended that permitting the Patriarch to conduct religious ceremonies at the church would amount to interference in its administration and would undermine the binding judicial pronouncements concerning the 1934 Constitution of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church.

“The Patriarch cannot claim any independent or unilateral ecclesiastical authority to enter the said church and conduct religious ceremonies in disregard of the applicable judgments, decrees and constitutional arrangements governing the church.” the petitioners submitted.

The petitioners relied on the decision in K.S. Varghese v. St. Peter's and St. Paul's Syrian Orthodox Church, wherein the Supreme Court authoritatively considered the constitutional governance and administration of the Malankara Church.

The petitioners also relied on the Supreme Court's earlier decision in Most Rev. P.M.A. Metropolitan and Others v. Moran Mar Marthoma Mathews and Another, [1995 Supp (4) SCC 286], which dealt with the validity of the 1934 Constitution and the authority of the Patriarch over the Malankara Church.

According to the petitioners, the Supreme Court had held that the Patriarch could not exercise unilateral authority over the administration of parish churches in derogation of the 1934 Constitution.

The petitioners further relied on a judgment dated November 17, 2021, passed by the Principal Munsiff's Court, Kottayam, in O.S. No. 851/2017. The said decree restrained Thomas Mar Themothious Metropolitan from entering the scheduled churches, including St. Mary's Church, Manarcad, and conducting religious services as Metropolitan. The petition states that the appeal against the decree was dismissed and the subsequent Regular Second Appeawas also dismissed by the High Court on February 24, 2026.

Reliance was also placed on the decree dated September 18, 2020, in O.S. No. 7/2019 passed by the Additional Sub Court, Kottayam, concerning the administration and management of St. Mary's Church in accordance with the 1934 Constitution.

The petitioners alleged that the decrees remained unimplemented and that execution proceedings in E.P. No. 12/2024 were pending before the Sub Court, Kottayam.

The High Court in its order recorded an incident concerning the attempted service of notice on respondents 5 to 7, who are the Jacobite Suriyani Christiani Sabha, Moran Mor Ignatius Aphrem III and Thomas Mar Themothios Metropolitan.

When the writ petition came up for consideration on November 12, 2026, the Court admitted the petition and directed that urgent notice be served on respondents 5 to 7 through a Special Messenger on the same day.

However, when the matter was taken up on November 13, the Special Messenger reported that he could not serve the notices and that someone had allegedly threatened him with the filing of a case against him before the High Court.

Taking note of the report, the Court observed:

"I am of the prima facie opinion that the jurisdictional Station House Officer should register a case against the authority concerned and do the needful in accordance with law."

The Court accordingly directed the Registry to forward the complaint submitted by the Special Messenger to the jurisdictional police station.

Considering the principal contention raised by the petitioners, the Court observed that there was force in the argument that the directions contained in M.A. Cherian and Ors. v Thomas Mar Themothious Metropolitan [O.S No. 851/ 2017] and Thomas Mar Themothious Metropolitan v M.A. Cherian [RSA 547/ 2026] and the Supreme Court judgment in K.S. Varghese should not be violated in connection with the Patriarch's visit.

The Court therefore directed the State Police Chief to ensure compliance with those judicial directions during the visit of the sixth respondent.

The Court also specifically directed the State Police Chief to ensure that the visa conditions issued to the Patriarch were not violated.

During the hearing, the Additional Advocate General submitted that certain clarifications had subsequently been made by the High Court in contempt appeal and connected cases concerning the earlier judicial directions.

Taking note of the submission, the Court directed the State Police Chief to consider those subsequent clarifications as well.

The writ petition has been posted to November 23, 2026.

Counsel for Petitioners: D. Koshore, Meera Gopinath


Tags: