Click the Play button to listen to article

Meghalaya High Court has quashed a POCSO case against a youth accused of aggravated penetrative sexual assault, observing that proceedings arose out of a consensual adolescent relationship and can be quashed where the parties had attained majority, were living together as husband and wife with their child.

A Single Judge Bench of Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere allowed a petition filed by the survivor, her mother and the accused seeking quashing of an FIR registered under Sections 5 and 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act).

The petitioners submitted that the survivor and the accused were in a consensual relationship and had been living together as husband and wife. They also had a seven month old child. Although both were minors at the time of the alleged incident they had attained majority by the time the High Court considered the petition. The survivor and her mother had consented to quashing the FIR.

The High Court sought a report from the Secretary of the High Court Legal Services Committee to ascertain whether the survivor's consent was informed and voluntary and whether she and her child had received government welfare benefits.

The report revealed that neither the survivor nor her child had received any such benefits. The Court subsequently directed the District Legal Services Authority and the District Child Protection Officer , East Khasi Hills to ensure that they received the benefits they were entitled to.

A subsequent report informed the Court that Rs. 1.5 lakh had been disbursed to the survivor as interim compensation under the Meghalaya Victim Compensation Scheme, 2022. The amount was deposited in a fixed deposit until she attains 25 years of age. She would be entitled to quarterly interest.

The High Court relied on its earlier judgment in Shri Shalenbor Wahlang and Anr. v. State of Meghalaya (Crl.Petn. No. 92 of 2023). In that case, the Court had held that POCSO proceedings could be quashed in exceptional cases involving consensual adolescent relationships.

The Court had in Shalenbor Wahlang observed, "That discretion has to be used with due care and caution and circumspection in exceptional cases, to do justice."

It had further emphasised the need to balance justice, deterrence and rehabilitation while considering such cases and said, "Rendering justice demands not only that the law be applied with precision, but also that it be tempered with fairness, compassion and empathy when the situation/facts of a case, warrant it."

Applying these principles, the High Court noted that the survivor and the accused had attained majority and had been living together as husband and wife for the last two years. Taking into account their child and the no objection given by the survivor and her mother, the Court found no impediment in allowing the petition.

The High Court accordingly allowed petition and quashed registered FIR along with proceedings pending before the Juvenile Justice Board.

The Court also directed concerned authorities to appoint a Support Person to assist the survivor in accessing further assistance for herself and her child.

Counsel for Petitioners: S. Deb, Legal Aid Counsel.

Counsel for Respondent: N.G. Shylla, Public Prosecutor.

Tags: