Concealment Of Pending Criminal Case In Verification Form By Constable Justifies Dismissal From Service: Patna High Court
A Division Bench of the Patna High Court comprising Chief Justice V. Kameswar Rao and Justice Partha Sarthy held that suppressing material information by a constable about pending criminal cases in a verification form before undergoing training, justifies dismissal from service.
Background Facts
The appellant was selected as a Constable and joined service on 01.08.2018. Before undergoing training, she submitted a verification form. she answered “No” against the query whether she had ever been accused in a criminal or civil case or sent to jail. Against the query whether any criminal case or civil suit was pending against her, she also answered “No”. However, an FIR had been lodged against her under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 504/34 of the Indian Penal Code, which was pending at the time of filling the form.
Due to suppression of information, a show cause notice dated 11.10.2018 was issued to her. Her defence was that she filled the form ignorantly and not deliberately, and the format of the form was not clear. The show cause notice resulted in her dismissal from service. Her appeal was rejected.
Aggrieved, the Constable filed a writ petition before the High Court. The High Court disposed of the writ petition directing the Deputy Inspector General of Police to dispose of her appeal. The appellate order was passed on 15.05.2019. The Single Judge dismissed her writ petition, upholding her dismissal.
Aggrieved by the same, the constable filed the Letters Patent Appeal before the Patna High Court.
It was argued by the Constable by relying upon the judgment in Avtar Singh Vs. Union of India & Ors., that where there is suppression or false information of involvement in a criminal case but conviction or acquittal had already been recorded before filing of the application/verification form and such fact later comes to the knowledge of the employer, it is not necessary that dismissal must follow.
On the other hand, it was argued by the respondents that the constable had concealed the criminal case pending against her. It was submitted that the appointment was made before the constable had filled the verification form wherein she concealed the material facts. It was only upon inquiries pursuant to the filling of the verification form that the criminal case came to the knowledge of the respondents, which resulted in her dismissal from service.
The respondents relied upon the judgment in State of U.P. and Anr. Vs. Dinesh Kumar, wherein it was held that proper and complete disclosure in applications for government employment is not a simple procedural formality but a basic requirement rooted in fairness, integrity and public trust.
Findings and Observations of the Court
It was observed by the Division Bench that the constable had concealed the case pending against her. Rules 365 and 673 of the Bihar Police Manual, 1978 provide that if the character of the man is reported to be bad or his statement false, he shall be removed from the force.
The judgment in Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited & Anr. vs. Anil Kanwariya was relied upon wherein it was held that if the question is about the credibility and trustworthiness of an employee who at the initial stage of employment made a false declaration or suppressed material facts of having involved in a criminal case, and then choice whether to continue or not to continue such an employee always must be given to the employer.
Further, the judgment in State of U.P. and Anr. Vs. Dinesh Kumar was relied upon, wherein it was held that complete disclosure in the application for government employment is not a simple procedural formality but a basic requirement rooted in fairness, integrity and public trust. It was further held that the gravity is significantly compounded when the non-disclosure is repeated, as it ceases to be accidental and instead reflects deliberate concealment.
Further, the judgment in Yogeeta Chandra Vrs. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. was relied upon wherein it was held that saying “No” to a query about figuring as an accused or complainant in any criminal case amounts to suppression of material facts.
It was held by the Division Bench that the appointment was made before the constable had filled the verification form wherein she concealed the material facts. Therefore, as per the Bihar Police Manual Clause 573(c), furnishing the false information resulted in dismissal from service.
With the aforesaid observations, the order of the Single Judge was upheld by the Division Bench. Consequently, the the Letters Patent Appeal filed by the Constable was dismissed by the Division Bench.
Counsel for the Appellant : Pranav Kumar, Advocate
Counsel for the Respondents : Manoj Kumar Singh, GA 8; Sanoj Kumar, AC to G.A.8