Click the Play button to listen to article

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has enhanced by Rs 5 lakh the compensation awarded to an advocate whose right leg had to be amputated above the knee following a 1994 road accident, holding that his subsequent professional success could not offset the lifelong loss of ordinary physical amenities.

“Professional success cannot be treated as a substitute for the loss of ordinary amenities of life,” observed Justice Deepak Gupta, adding that the claimant's inability to walk normally, restrictions on physical activity, dependence on a prosthesis, discomfort and inconvenience “constitute distinct non-pecuniary losses which require appropriate compensation.”

At the same time, the Court declined to award compensation for future loss of earning capacity, holding that “the functional disability of an advocate cannot be equated with that of a person, whose livelihood depends predominantly upon physical labour or mobility.”

On May 28, 1994, the appellant, a practising advocate, was standing on the side of a road in Jalandhar when he was struck by a car driven rashly and negligently, suffering severe injuries to his right lower limb, including fractures, vascular damage and infection.

In July 1999, the Tribunal awarded him about Rs 3.57 lakh with interest. While his appeal for enhancement was pending in the High Court, his right leg was amputated above the knee on May 29, 2006, owing to persistent infection, non-healing wounds and deformity. The High Court permitted additional evidence in 2014 and remitted the matter to the Tribunal in 2017.

By award dated March 14, 2019, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jalandhar, raised the compensation to about Rs 11.70 lakh, adding about Rs 7.12 lakh for subsequent treatment, the artificial limb and attendant charges, and Rs 1 lakh for pain and suffering. The claimant appealed again, seeking further enhancement.

Counsel for the appellant argued that despite the eventual amputation and years of treatment, the Tribunal had failed to award adequate compensation for transportation, replacement of the artificial limb, loss of income during treatment, future loss of earning capacity, loss of amenities, and mental agony.

The insurer contended that the Tribunal had considered all the evidence, and that the appellant's income had in fact increased after the accident, as he continued his legal practice and later served as Presiding Officer of a Debt Recovery Tribunal. It argued that there was no proof of actual loss of earning capacity and that several claims were unsupported or excessive.

No loss of earning capacity

Relying on R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) and Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, the Court reiterated that the percentage of permanent physical disability is not necessarily the percentage of loss of earning capacity, which depends on the nature of the claimant's work.

The Court accepted the medical evidence that the amputation was a continuing consequence of the accident, with a disability certificate assessing 80% permanent disability in relation to the amputated limb.

However, noting that the appellant's work “principally involved intellectual and legal skills,” that he acknowledged a rise in his income, and that he was appointed Presiding Officer of a Debt Recovery Tribunal in April 2013, it held there was no justification for applying the multiplier method “merely on the basis of 80% disability of the amputated limb.”

It also declined to enhance the Rs 20,000 already awarded for loss of income during treatment, in the absence of cogent evidence of greater actual loss, and found no reason to reopen the amounts the Tribunal had allowed for medical expenses, the artificial limb and attendant charges.

Future prosthesis and incidental expenses

The Court held that the Tribunal had erred in making no provision for future replacement of the artificial limb, which a witness from an artificial limb centre testified had a limited useful life.

“The absence of proof of the precise cost of a future prosthesis does not justify complete denial of compensation under this head,” the Court said, though it declined to accept the witness's estimate of Rs 10-12 lakh without evidence of the specific prosthesis required.

On transportation, it held that claims for engaging an associate advocate, personal assistance, massage and travel were not backed by reliable evidence, and that professional assistance costs could not automatically be treated as a loss caused by the accident.

Even so, the repeated hospitalisation and amputation showed that transport and incidental expenses must have been incurred, and “the appellant cannot be denied reasonable compensation merely because every visit is not supported by a separate receipt.”

Loss of amenities distinct from pain and suffering

The Court held that the Tribunal's award for pain and suffering could not be merged with compensation for loss of amenities. “Pain and suffering arising from treatment and operations are distinct from the lifelong deprivation of normal physical activities and enjoyment of life,” it observed, adding that the claimant, even with an artificial limb, “cannot be expected to enjoy the same degree of physical mobility, comfort and independence as before the accident.”

Assessing compensation “conservatively” to avoid duplication, the Court awarded an additional Rs 1.5 lakh for loss of amenities, permanent inconvenience and hardship, Rs 50,000 for transportation and incidental expenses, and Rs 3 lakh as a lump sum for future replacement of the artificial limb, raising the total compensation to about Rs 16.70 lakh.

The Court directed that the additional Rs 2 lakh for transportation, loss of amenities and hardship will carry interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition, while the Rs 3 lakh for the future prosthesis will carry 6% interest from the date of judgment, “since it represents provision for future expenditure.” The insurer was directed to deposit the enhanced amount within eight weeks.

Mr. D.K. Gupta, Advocate for the appellant.

Mr. Radhe Shyam Sharma, Advocate for respondent No.4- Insurance Company.

Tags: