Father-In-Law Commits Suicide Amid Son's Matrimonial Dispute: P&H High Court Quashes Abetment FIR Against Woman's Family
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has quashed, on the basis of a compromise, an FIR for abetment of suicide under Section 108 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. The FIR was registered against a woman and her family members after her father-in-law died by suicide.
Justice Shalini Singh Nagpal held that the State's reliance on the Supreme Court's decision in Daxaben v. State of Gujarat did not stop the Court from first examining whether the allegations disclosed the offence at all.
Taking the allegations at face value, the Court held,
“Even if the allegations are accepted at their face value, harassment suffered by the deceased at the hands of petitioners on account of matrimonial discord between his son and petitioner No.1, cannot, by any stretch of imagination, amount to abetment or incitement to commit suicide.”
The FIR was registered on April 20, 2026, under Sections 108, 351(2) and 61(2) of the BNS. The complainant said he married in April 2024, after which disputes arose with his wife. Several attempts at reconciliation by respectable persons and relatives failed, and his wife returned to her parents' home.
According to the complainant, at a meeting of a farmers' committee in Ajnala on April 12, 2026, his wife's brother and cousin threatened him and his family with death and cast aspersions on his character in front of the panchayat. His father, a postman, became mentally stressed and died by suicide days later. The complainant said his father left a suicide note.
The parties later entered into a compromise dated July 7, 2026, and the Judicial Magistrate, Amritsar, reported that it was genuine and voluntary. The State did not dispute the compromise. However, it argued that abetment of suicide is a non-compoundable and heinous offence, and that under Daxaben the FIR could not be quashed on the basis of a compromise.
Daxaben Does Not Bar Examination Of Allegations
The Court acknowledged that courts must be cautious about quashing grave offences only because of a compromise. It held, however, that “while considering the quashing petition on the basis of compromise, this Court is not prevented from determining whether from the allegations in the FIR, offence punishable under Section 108 BNS is at all made out.”
It distinguished Daxaben, “In Daxaben's case, the Supreme court did not examine the question whether the FIR in that case disclosed any offence under Section 306 IPC, as the High Court quashed the proceedings on the sole ground of compromise."
In the present case, the present case no offence under Section 108 BNS is attracted and the matter stands amicably resolved between the petitioners and the complainant, who are family members.
Ms. Navjot Kaur, Advocate for Mr. B.S. Bhalla, Advocate for petitioners.
Mr. Sukhbeer Singh, DAG, Punjab.
Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocate for respondent No.2.