No Habeas Corpus Against Minor's Placement In Children Home: P&H High Court Refuses To Let POCSO Victim Live With Accused's Mother
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that a writ of habeas corpus cannot be issued for the release of a minor placed in a Children Home under an order of the Child Welfare Committee (CWC), unless that order is shown to be without jurisdiction or wholly illegal.Justice Manisha Batra dismissed a petition by the mother of a man facing trial under Section 64 of the BNS and Section 6 of...
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that a writ of habeas corpus cannot be issued for the release of a minor placed in a Children Home under an order of the Child Welfare Committee (CWC), unless that order is shown to be without jurisdiction or wholly illegal.
Justice Manisha Batra dismissed a petition by the mother of a man facing trial under Section 64 of the BNS and Section 6 of the POCSO Act, who sought custody of the 17-year-old victim and her infant daughter from a Children Home in Jalandhar.
The Court held that though the minor had expressed a wish to live with the petitioner, “the wish of a minor cannot, by itself, override the statutory scheme framed for her own protection.”
The petitioner claimed that her son and the girl had fallen in love and married against the wishes of the girl's parents, and that a daughter was born to them. On the complaint of the girl's father, an FIR was registered in August 2025, to which offences under Section 64 BNS and Section 6 POCSO Act were later added.
According to the State, the girl was recovered from the accused's company in February 2026 along with her two-month-old child. As per her school record, she was about 16 years and 3 months old at the time of the alleged occurrence and is now about 17 years and 5 months.
Since she was unwilling to return to her parents, the CWC ordered on March 2, 2026, that she and her daughter be placed in the Children Home at Gandhi Vanita Ashram, Jalandhar. The accused is on bail, the challan has been filed and charges framed.
When produced before the High Court, the girl stated that she wanted to live with the petitioner, whom she described as her mother-in-law.
Counsel for the petitioner argued that the girl had told both the CWC and the High Court that she wished to live in her matrimonial home, that a minor cannot be confined in a Nari Niketan against her will, and that the High Court had in similar cases handed over minor girls to their mothers-in-law. Reliance was placed on decisions including Preeti v. State of Haryana and Chhalo Rani v. State of Punjab.
The State submitted that the CWC's order was passed by a competent authority, that the petitioner was neither the natural nor de facto guardian, that no evidence of marriage surfaced during investigation, and that handing the victim to the accused's mother could lead to her being influenced against deposing, affecting a fair trial.
Habeas corpus not maintainable against CWC order
The Court explained that a CWC, constituted under Section 27 of the JJ Act, functions as a Bench with the powers of a Magistrate, that a sexually abused child is a “child in need of care and protection” under Section 2(14), that Section 19(6) of the POCSO Act requires such cases to be reported to the CWC, and that the CWC may order placement in a Children Home under Section 37, subject to appeal under Section 101.
Relying on the Supreme Court's case in Manubhai Ratilal Patel v. State of Gujarat, which held that habeas corpus will not lie where a person is in custody under an order of a competent court unless it is without jurisdiction, mechanical or wholly illegal, the Court held the principle applies equally to a CWC order.
It also relied on the Allahabad High Court Full Bench in Km. Rachna v. State of U.P., which held that even an irregular exercise of jurisdiction by a CWC sending a victim to a protective home cannot be treated as illegal detention, and on a Coordinate Bench ruling in Harish v. State of Haryana.
The Court noted that the petitioner had neither placed the CWC's order on record nor sought its quashing, and had not availed the remedy of appeal. Non-supply of a copy of the order, it held, did not render the custody illegal.
Best interest of the child
The High Court examined whether the girl's best interest would be served by handing her over to the petitioner, and found that it would not. Under Section 37 of the JJ Act, the child's wishes are one relevant factor alongside the Social Investigation Report, with the child's best interest under Section 3 remaining paramount.
The Court noted that the petitioner is the mother of the main accused, who is on bail and lives in the same locality, so handing over custody “would, in effect, place her back in the family of the accused.”
With the trial at the threshold and the girl being the most material witness, the State's apprehension that she could be influenced “cannot be said to be unfounded.” It also noted that the petition was filed more than seven months after the placement order, after charges had been framed, without explanation.
On the claimed marriage, the Court found no document showing it was solemnised, and held that even assuming it, “a claimed marriage does not take a child out of the protective scheme of the JJ Act and the POCSO Act.” The petitioner, it said, has no enforceable right to custody, which can be given to a fit person or facility only after inquiry by the CWC.
The Court distinguished Preeti and Chhalo Rani, noting that Preeti involved no POCSO offence and Chhalo Rani involved Section 8 of the POCSO Act, whereas here charges under Section 64 BNS and Section 6 POCSO had been framed and the girl had given birth. In Preeti, the boy was about 18, whereas the accused here is about 37. In both cases a marriage was prima facie shown, unlike here, and neither involved a pending trial or an apprehension of the victim being influenced.
The Court held that the condition imposed in Chhalo Rani, restraining the son from consummating the marriage until the girl attained majority, “would also be meaningless in the present case,” since the cohabitation was itself the subject of the charges. It observed:
“Handing over her custody to his mother, while he is on bail, would expose the detenue to the very situation from which the law seeks to protect her.”
It added that neither ruling considered the maintainability of habeas corpus against a CWC order in light of Manubhai Ratilal Patel, or the remedy of appeal under Section 101. The Court also noted that Balwinder Singh v. State of Punjab, which held that a minor cannot be detained in a Nari Niketan against her wishes, predated both the POCSO Act and the JJ Act, 2015.
Dismissing the petition, the Court directed the Superintendent of the Children Home to ensure that the girl and her daughter receive proper care, medical attention and counselling, and that the girl is given access to education or vocational training.
The Court left the petitioner or the girl free to approach the CWC for review of the placement order or to file an appeal under Section 101, to be decided after hearing her and considering her wishes, the Social Investigation Report and the pendency of the trial. The Court clarified that on attaining majority, the girl will be free to decide where she lives.
Mr. Ashok Kumar Khunger, Advocate for the petitioner.
Ms. Sakshi Bakshi, AAG, Punjab.