Rajasthan High Court Takes Suo Motu Cognisance Of Huge Gap Between Property Market Value And Circle Rates, Flags Black Money Concerns
The Rajasthan High Court has initiated a suo-motu petition over huge discrepancy between the prevailing District Level Committee (“DLC”) rate and the market value of an immovable property, inasmuch as it found that DLC rates were almost 70 times lower than the market value.
While expressing surprise and terming the matter to be of wider public interest, the bench of Justice Baljinder Singh Sandhu opined that such substantial disparity raised concerns regarding potential loss of revenue to the State as well as the possibilities of transactions involving black money.
For context, the Court was hearing certain bail applications, during which it flagged out an issue regarding substantial disparity in the DLC Rate and the actual market value of a land situated in Jalore.
It was highlighted that while the DLC Rate was Rs. 8 Lakhs, the actual market value was Rs. 5.51 Crores. However, owing to the DLC rates, the registration of the sale deed happened at Rs. 8 Lakhs.
“The DLC is constituted to determine the rates of immovable property after conducting a survey and assessing the prevailing market value, with a view to fixing rates that reasonably reflect the market value of the property. The purpose of fixing such rates is, inter alia, to curb transactions involving unaccounted money and prevent the evasion of stamp duty. Although some variation between the DLC rates and the actual market value may be inevitable, an exorbitant disparity between the two may facilitate the circulation of unaccounted money and cash transactions representing the difference between the actual market value and the value declared in the registered instrument.”
In this background, the Court observed that fixation of appropriate DLC rate was essential to discourage undervaluation of the property, use of unaccounted money in transactions, and evasion of stamp duty.
The Court highlighted that it had earlier flagged such discrepancy, and a copy of that order was forwarded to the Principle Secretary, Revenue, for immediate action, however, no action was taken in this regard.
In this light, opining that since it would not be appropriate to deal with a matter concerning State revenue and determination of DLC rate while exercising bail jurisdiction, the Court directed registration of the suo motu petition and its placement before the Chief Justice.