Hindu Marriage Can't Be Dissolved Through Community Separation Deed Unless Custom Is Established: Rajasthan High Court
The Rajasthan High Court has held that a Hindu marriage cannot be treated as dissolved merely on the basis of a community separation deed unless the customary practice permitting such dissolution is duly established.A Division Bench of Justice Arun Monga and Justice Yogendra Kumar Purohit dismissed an appeal challenging a Family Court's refusal to recognise the dissolution of a marriage through...
The Rajasthan High Court has held that a Hindu marriage cannot be treated as dissolved merely on the basis of a community separation deed unless the customary practice permitting such dissolution is duly established.
A Division Bench of Justice Arun Monga and Justice Yogendra Kumar Purohit dismissed an appeal challenging a Family Court's refusal to recognise the dissolution of a marriage through a customary separation deed, observing that the parties had failed to establish the existence of the custom relied upon.
The Court further observed that instead of seeking a declaration of dissolution of marriage through a civil suit without establishing the alleged custom, the parties could seek divorce under the appropriate provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
The matter arose from a suit filed by a woman seeking a declaration that her marriage had already been dissolved through a social separation deed known as “Samajik Chhutpalla”, executed in 2000, allegedly in accordance with the customs and practices prevailing in her community.
The Family Court dismissed the suit, holding that the woman had failed to establish the existence of the alleged customary practice of divorce or demonstrate that it had been continuously and uniformly followed for a sufficiently long period to acquire the force of law.
Aggrieved by the decision, the woman approached the High Court.
It was argued on her behalf that the customary divorce agreement, bearing the signatures of several members of the community, was sufficient to establish the existence and observance of the practice. She further contended that the respondent had admitted the customary divorce and that the parties had not been cohabiting.
After considering the submissions, the High Court agreed with the Family Court's finding that the parties had failed to prove the customary practice on the basis of which they claimed that the marriage stood dissolved.
The Court emphasised that the existence of a customary mode of divorce must be established before a marriage can be treated as having been dissolved in accordance with such a practice. The mere execution of a community separation deed was insufficient in the absence of proof of the custom.
"None of the parties could even prove any of the prevalent customs by which they claimed themselves to be governed to have sought dissolution of marriage on the basis of it."
Accordingly, the Court dismissed the appeal.